| 1980 | 1981 | 1982 | 1983 | 1984 | 1985 | 1986 | 1987 | 1988 | 1989 | 1990 | 1991 | 1992 | 1993 | 1994 |
| 1995 | 1996 | 1997 | 1998 | 1999 | 2000 | 2001 | 2002 | 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 |
| 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 | 2023 | 2024 |
| 1980 (Rob Searl, 6-4-0) |
| Captains: Marty Roberts, Dave Snyder |
| Monroe CC 2, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Ithaca JV 5, Nazareth 2 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Houghton JV 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 9, Daemen 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, St. Bonaventure JV 0 (H) |
| Cornell 'B' 3, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 5, Daemen 1 (A) |
| Elmira 6, Nazareth 2 (A) |
| Nazareth 6, Hamilton JV 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Alfred Tech 2 (H) |
|
| 1981 (Rob Searl, 5-7-1) |
| Captains: Marty Roberts, Dave Snyder, Dan Brone |
| Nazareth 1, Roberts Wesleyan 1 ot (A) |
| Nazareth 3, Canisius 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, St. John Fisher 1 (A) |
| Elmira 2, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 4, Eisenhower 0 (H) |
| Fredonia 4, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Buffalo State 4, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 6, Daemen 1 (H) |
| Geneseo 2, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| RIT 4, Nazareth 2 (A) |
| Houghton 2, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Cornell 'B' (H) |
| St. Bonaventure 3, Nazareth 1 (A) |
|
| 1982 (Rob Searl, 12-2-3) |
| Captain: Bill Maloy, Ed Schuler |
| Nazareth 1, Ohio Wesleyan 1 ot (A) Ohio Wesleyan Tournament |
| Nazareth 2, Oberlin 1 (N) Ohio Wesleyan Tournament |
| Nazareth 6, Canisius 3 (A) |
| Nazareth 10, Utica College 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, St. John Fisher 1 (H) |
| Elmira 4, Nazareth 2 (A) |
| Nazareth 4, Roberts Wesleyan 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Fredonia 3 ot (A) |
| Buffalo State 1, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Hamilton 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Hobart 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 3, Geneseo 2 (A) |
| Nazareth 5, Utica 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Houghton 2 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, RIT 2 ot (H) |
| Nazareth 6, Daemen 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 3, St. Bonaventure 2 ot (H) |
|
| 1983 (Rob Searl, 12-2-1) |
| Captains: Tony D'Aiuto, Keith Woedy, John Zatyko |
| Nazareth 5, LeMoyne 0 (H, exhibition) |
| Buffalo St. 2, Nazareth 1 (H, exhibition) |
| Nazareth 3, Canisius 2 ot (H) |
| Nazareth 4, Utica College 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Elmira 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 1, Utica Tech 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 1, Roberts Wesleyan 1 ot (A) |
| Fredonia 2, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 4, Niagara 2 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Hamilton 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 3, Hobart 1 ot (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Geneseo 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 4, St. John Fisher 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Houghton 1 ot (H) |
| RIT 4, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 5, Daemen 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, St. Bonaventure 0 (A) |
|
| 1984 (Rob Searl, 6-9-2) |
| Captains: Keith Woedy, Bob Lasher |
| Nazareth 0, E. Conn. 0 ot (N) at Casleton |
| Castleton 2, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 1, Potsdam 1 ot (A) |
| Nazareth 5, Utica College 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Elmira 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 6, Roberts Wesleyan 0 (H) |
| Fredonia 1, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 3, Niagara 2 (H) |
| Buffalo State 1, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Hobart 2, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Geneseo 2, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, St. John Fisher 0 (H) |
| Houghton 2, Nazareth 1 ot (A) |
| RIT 1, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 4, Canisius 2 (A) |
| St. Bonaventure 4, Nazareth 3 (H) |
| Rochester, Univ. of 2, Nazareth 1 (A) |
|
| 1985 (Rob Searl, 12-4-1) |
| Captains: Dan Brone, Bob Lasher, Graeme Tosh |
| Nazareth 3, Oswego 2, ot (H) Exhibition |
| Nazareth 2, Cornell 'B' 1, ot (H) Exhibition |
| Nazareth 3, Potsdam 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Utica College 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, St. John Fisher 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 3, Roberts Wesleyan 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 1, Buffalo State 0 (H) |
| Fredonia 3, Nazareth 2, ot (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Niagara 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 3, Clarkson 3 ot (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Hobart 1, ot (H) |
| Nazareth 5, Geneseo 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, LeMoyne 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Houghton 0 (H) |
| RIT 2, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| St. Bonaventure 3, Nazareth 2, ot (A) |
| Nazareth 4, Rochester 1, (H) |
| Nazareth 5, Elmira 0 (H) |
| Rochester 3, Nazareth 1, ot (H) ECAC Tournament |
|
| 1986 (Rob Searl, 8-11-1) |
| Captains: Mike Deckman, Dan Brone, Peter Costanza |
| Castleton, Vt. 2, Nazareth 1, ot (A) |
| Nazareth 5, Allegheny 3, ot (N) Alfred Tournament |
| Alfred 2, Nazareth 1 (A) Alfred Tournament |
| Nazareth 4, Utica 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 1, Stony Brook 0 (N) Drew Tournament |
| Gettysburg 3, Nazareth 1 (N) Drew Tournament |
| Nazareth 4, Roberts Wesleyan 2 (H) |
| Buffalo State 2, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Fredonia State 2, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 5, Niagara 0 (H) |
| Hobart 3, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Geneseo 2 ot (A) |
| LeMoyne 2, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, St. John Fisher 0 (H) |
| RIT 3, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Houghton 4, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| St. Bonaventure 1, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Rochester 2, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 1, Clarkson 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Elmira 1 (A) |
|
| 1987 (Rob Searl, 11-6-1) |
| Captains: Mike Deckman, Lee Casler |
| Nazareth 2, Cornell 'B' 1 (H) Nazareth Tournament |
| E.Connecticut St. 4, Nazareth 0 (H) Nazareth Tournament |
| Clarkson 4, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, St. John Fisher 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 4, Roberts Wesleyan 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Buffalo State 1, ot (H) |
| Fredonia State 4, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Utica 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 1, Hamilton 1 ot (A) |
| Nazareth 1, Hobart 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Geneseo State 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 4, LeMoyne 2 (A) |
| Nazareth 4, Elmira 0 (H) |
| RIT 4, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Houghton 0 (H) |
| Ithaca 3, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 1, St. Bonaventure 0 (A) |
| Rochester 2, Nazareth 0 (H) |
|
| 1988 (Rob Searl, 13-7-1) |
| Captains: Andy DuMont, John Viglucci |
| RIT 3, Nazareth 1 (A) RIT Tournament |
| Nazareth 4, Allegheny 2 (A) RIT Tournament |
| Nazareth 2, St. John Fisher 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Roberts Wesleyan 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 1, Buffalo State 0 (A) Buffalo State Tournament |
| Allegheny 2, Nazareth 0 (A) Buffalo State Tournament |
| Nazareth 1, Fredonia State 1, ot (A) |
| Nazareth 5, Utica 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Hamilton 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 4, Hobart 2 (A) |
| Geneseo State 3, Nazareth 2, ot (A) |
| Nazareth 4, Elmira 2, ot (A) |
| Nazareth 3, LeMoyne 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Master's (Calif.) 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 1, Point Loma (Calif.) 0 (A) |
| UC-San Diego 3, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Houghton 1 (A) |
| Ithaca 3, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 5, St. Bonaventure 2 (H) |
| Clarkson 3, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| Alfred 2, Nazareth 1 (A) |
|
| 1989 (Rob Searl, 7-7-4) |
| Captains: Alan Pascuzzi, Bill Thomson, Brian Burke |
| Nazareth 2, St. John Fisher 0 (H) |
| Gannon 4, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Clarkson 2, Nazareth 1, ot (A) |
| CCNY 3, Nazareth 1 (N) at Drew Tournament |
| Nazareth 2, Kutztown 1 (N) at Drew Tournament |
| Nazareth 2, Roberts Wesleyan 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 1, Fredonia State 1, ot (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Utica 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 0, Hamilton 0, ot (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Hobart 2, ot (H) |
| Nazareth 0, Geneseo State 0, ot (H) |
| Ithaca 1, Nazareth 0, ot (A) |
| LeMoyne 2, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| RIT 3, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 4, Houghton 2 (H) |
| Nazareth 1, St. Bonaventure 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, St. John Fisher 1 (A) |
| Alfred 2, Nazareth 0, ot (H) |
|
| 1990 (Rob Searl, 8-8-0) |
| Captains: Alan Pascuzzi, Griff Hannel, Dave Knieriemen |
| Buffalo 2, Nazareth 1 (H) East Ave. Invitational |
| Nazareth 3, Fisher 1 (A) East Ave. Invitational |
| John Carroll 4, Nazareth 3, ot (A) |
| Roberts Wesleyan 3, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 5, Fredonia State 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Oswego State 0 (H) |
| Hamilton 1, Nazareth 0, ot (H) |
| Nazareth 1, Hobart 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Geneseo State 0 (A) |
| Ithaca 1, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 5, LeMoyne 3 (H) |
| RIT 3, Nazareth 2, ot (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Houghton 0 (A) |
| Clarkson 3, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 1, St. John Fisher 0 (H) |
| Alfred 2, Nazareth 1 (A) |
|
| 1991 (Rob Searl, 5-10-0) |
| Captains: Brian Ashe, Gregg Klingenberg, Jeff Mandell |
| Nazareth 2, Scranton 0 (H) East Ave. Invitational |
| Wilkes College 2, Nazareth 0 (H) East Ave. Invitational |
| Geneseo State 2, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| John Carroll 3, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Roberts Wesleyan 1 (A) |
| Fredonia State 2, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| LeMoyne 3, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 1, Hamilton 0 (A) |
| Hobart 5, Nazareth 3, ot (H) |
| Ithaca 2, Nazareth 0, ot (A) |
| RIT 6, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Houghton 2, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| Clarkson 6, Nazareth 2 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, St. John Fisher 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 3, Alfred 2 (H) |
|
| 1992 (Rob Searl, 3-11-1) |
| Captains: Kevin Burke, Jeff Mandell |
| Ohio Wesleyan 6, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Bethany 3, Nazareth 2 (N) at Ohio Wesleyan |
| Roberts Wesleyan 2, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, LeMoyne 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 1, Fredonia State 1 (A) |
| Geneseo State 2, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 1, Hamilton 0 (H) |
| Hobart 6, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Ithaca 2, Nazareth 1, ot (H) |
| RIT 2, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Clarkson 3, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, St. John Fisher 1 (H) |
| Houghton 4, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Elmira 4, Nazareth 2 (A) |
| Alfred 8, Nazareth 0 (A) |
|
| 1993 Rob Searl, 4-13-0) |
| Captain: Chris Murtha |
| Va. Wesleyan 5, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Randolph-Macon 6, Nazareth 0 (N) at Va. Wesleyan |
| Roberts Wesleyan 3, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 4, Penn State-Behrend 1 (N) at Brockport Tournament |
| Brockport 1, Nazareth 0 (A) at Brockport Tournament |
| Fredonia State 3, Nazareth 2, ot (H) |
| Hamilton 2, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Hobart 7, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Ithaca 6, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| RIT 2, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Geneseo State 1, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Clarkson 2, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 4, St. John Fisher 0 (A) |
| Houghton 2, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 1, Elmira 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Alfred 2 (H) |
|
| 1994 (Rob Searl, 6-9-2) |
| Captains: Peter Gierczak, Kirk Pero |
| Houghton 1, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 1, Roberts Wesleyan 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 4, Keuka 0 (N) at Brockport Tournament |
| Nazareth 2, Brockport 0 (A) at Brockport Tournament |
| Fredonia 3, Nazareth 2 (A) |
| Nazareth 3, Penn State-Behrend 1 (H) |
| Hamilton 1, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Hobart 1, ot (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Ithaca 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 1, LeMoyne 1, ot (H) |
| RIT 2, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Geneseo 2, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Clarkson 2, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| St. John Fisher 2, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| St. Lawrence 2, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Elmira 2, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 0, Alfred 0, ot (A) |
|
| 1995 (Rob Searl, 7-11-1) |
| Captains: Pete Gierczak, Jim Tiffin |
| Green Mountain 4, Nazareth 2 (N) Plattsburgh Tournament |
| Nazareth 5, Thomas 0 (N) Plattsburgh Tournament |
| Nazareth 2, Oswego 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 1, Allegheny 0 (N) Brockport Tournament |
| Nazareth 1, Brockport 0 (A) Brockport Tournament |
| Fredonia 2, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Roberts 1, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Hamilton 1, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 1, Hobart 1, ot (H) |
| Ithaca 3, Nazareth 1, ot (A) |
| Penn State-Behrend 4, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, St. John Fisher 0 (A) |
| RIT 2, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Geneseo 0 (H) |
| Rochester 2, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| St. Lawrence 2, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| Clarkson 2, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Elmira 4, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 1, Alfred 0 (H) |
|
| 1996 (Doug May, 2-11-5) |
| Captains: Brad Stocum, Jim Tiffin |
| Nazareth 3, Roberts 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 0, Oswego 0, ot (A) |
| Nazareth 3, Johnson State 0 (N) New Paltz Tournament |
| Nazareth 1, New Paltz 1, ot (A) New Paltz Tournament |
| Note: Nazareth won tournament by virtue of 4-3 advantage in penalty kicks |
| Fredonia 5, Nazareth 2 (A) |
| Plattsburgh 4, Nazareth 2 (H) |
| Nazareth 1, Hamilton 1, ot (H) |
| Hobart 1, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Ithaca 2, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Skidmore 1, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| St. John Fisher 1, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| RIT 2, Nazareth 1, ot (H) |
| Nazareth 0, Geneseo 0, ot (A) |
| Rochester 1, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| St. Lawrence 5, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Clarkson 4, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Elmira 3, ot (A) |
| Alfred 1, Nazareth 0 (A) |
|
| 1997 (Doug May, 5-9-2) |
| Captains: Jeff Fisher, Jim Tiffin |
| Nazareth 2, Oswego State 1 (H) |
| Fredonia 3, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| Skidmore 2, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 1, Plattsburgh 0 (A) |
| Hamilton 2, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Hobart 2, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| Ithaca 4, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 1, St. John Fisher 0, ot (A) |
| RIT 1, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Geneseo 1, ot (H) |
| Rochester 1, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 0, St. Lawrence 0, ot (A) |
| Clarkson 1, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Elmira 3, Nazareth 2 (H) |
| Nazareth 4, Alfred 0 (H) |
|
| 1998 (Doug May, 3-12-0) |
| Captains: Kyle Bolster, Kevin Flynn, Zach Wein |
| Oswego 3, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Fredonia 2, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 8, Cazenovia 1 (H) |
| Hamilton 2, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| Hobart 2, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Ithaca 5, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Plattsburgh 2, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, St. John Fisher 1 (A) |
| RIT 3, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| Geneseo 1, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Rochester 3, Nazareth 2 (H) |
| St. Lawrence 4, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Clarkson 5, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Elmira 4, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 3, Alfred 2, ot (A) |
|
| 1999 (Doug May 10-7-1 overall, 3-3 Empire 8) |
| Captains: Jamie Berardicurti, Colin Boughter |
| Oswego 1, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Buffalo State 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Keuka 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Utica 0 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 11, Cazenovia 0 (H) |
| Hamilton 5, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 3, Hobart 2 (H) |
| Ithaca 2, Nazareth 0 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 1, Plattsburgh 1, ot (A) |
| St. John Fisher 2, Nazareth 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 1, RIT 0 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 3, Geneseo 2 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Rochester 1 (H) |
| St. Lawrence 5, Nazareth 2 (A) |
| Nazareth 4, Clarkson 0 (A) |
| Elmira 2, Nazareth 1 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 4, Alfred 3 (H) E8 |
| Fredonia 1, Nazareth 0 (A) ECAC Northeast Tournament |
|
| 2000 (Doug May 11-5-2 overall, 3-1-2 Empire 8) |
| Captains: Zack Brooks, Steve Fisher, Brian Harding |
| Nazareth 5, Buffalo State 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Keuka 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Cazenovia 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Hamilton 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 1, Hobart 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 3, Ithaca 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 6, Utica 1 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 2, Oswego 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 1, RIT 1, ot (H) E8 |
| Geneseo 2, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Rochester 4, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| St. Lawrence 1, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 1, Clarkson 0 (H) |
| Elmira 2, Nazareth 1 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 2, Alfred 1, ot (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 2, St. John Fisher 2, ot (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 2, Fredonia 1 (A) ECAC Northeast Tournament at Fredonia |
| Rochester 1, Nazareth 0 (N) ECAC Northeast Tournament at Fredonia |
| *ECAC Northeast Tournament at Fredonia |
|
| 2001 (Doug May, 4-10-1 overall, 2-4 Empire 8) |
| Captains: Brian Harding, T.J. Lynch, Kevin May |
| Rochester 3, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Buffalo State 1 (A) |
| Keuka 2, Nazareth 1, ot (H) |
| St. John Fisher 4, Nazareth 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 2, Hobart 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 5, Utica 0 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 0, Oswego 0, ot (H) |
| RIT 5, Nazareth 2 (A) E8 |
| Geneseo 1, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Ithaca 3, Nazareth 0 (A) E8 |
| St. Lawrence 4, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Clarkson 3, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 1, Elmira 0, ot (H) E8 |
| Alfred 1, Nazareth 0 (H) E8 |
| Hamilton 2, Nazareth 0 (A) |
|
| 2002 (Doug May, 12-5-1 overall, 4-1-1 Empire 8) |
| Captains: T.J. Lynch, Kevin May, Eric Thomas, Kevin Thornton |
| Nazareth 1, Geneseo 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 6, Clarkson 3 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Buffalo State 0 (H) |
| Ithaca 2, Nazareth 1 (H) E8 |
| Hamilton 2, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 4, Elmira 2 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 2, St. John Fisher 0 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 8, Cazenovia 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 9, Hilbert 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Alfred 0 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 3, Oswego 2, ot (A) |
| Rochester 3, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 4, Utica 1 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 0, RIT 0, ot (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 3, Hobart 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 1, RIT 0 (N) E8 Tournament at Ithaca |
| Ithaca 2, Nazareth 1 (A) E8 Tournament at Ithaca |
| Keuka 2, Nazareth 0 (A) |
|
| 2003 (Doug May, 8-5-3 overall, 3-2-1 Empire 8) |
| Captains: Scott Chapman, Jefferson Dargout, Tom Moyer |
| Geneseo 3, Nazareth 2, ot (H) |
| Nazareth 0, Clarkson 0, ot (A) |
| Nazareth 1, Buffalo State 0 (A) |
| Ithaca 2, Nazareth 1 (A) E8 |
| Hamilton 4, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Elmira 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 1, St. John Fisher 1, ot (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 3, Alfred 1 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 5, Oswego 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Keuka 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 5, Cazenovia 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Utica 0 (A) E8 |
| RIT 3, Nazareth 0 (A) E8 |
| Hobart 2, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, St. John Fisher 1, ot (N) E8 Tournament at Ithaca |
| Nazareth 1, Alfred 1, ot (N) E8 Tournament at Ithaca, Alfred gains NCAA berth on penalty kicks, 4-1 |
|
| 2004 (Danny Gilbertson, 5-10-0 overall, 2-4 Empire 8) |
| Captains: Mike Deichmiller, Doug Rohr, Gavin Thomas |
| Geneseo 1, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 3, Colby-Sawyer 0 (N) Doug May Tournament at RIT |
| Nazareth 6, Gallaudet 0 (N) Doug May Tournament at RIT |
| Buffalo State 2, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| Hamilton 2, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| Ithaca 2, Nazareth 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 4, Elmira 0 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 4, Clarkson 1 (H) |
| St. John Fisher 4, Nazareth 1 (A) E8 |
| Oswego 3, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Alfred 1, Nazareth 0 (A) E8 |
| Allegheny 2, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Hobart 3, Nazareth 2, ot (H) |
| Nazareth 1, Utica 0 (H) E8 |
| RIT 1, Nazareth 0 (H) E8 |
|
| 2005 (Danny Gilbertson, 6-10-5 overall, 3-3 Empire 8) |
| Captains: Mike Deichmiller, Gavin Thomas |
| Geneseo 2, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 1, Allegheny 1, ot (H) Doug May Tournament |
| Nazareth 1, Plymouth State 1, ot (H) Doug May Tournament |
| Buffalo State 2, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Hamilton 2, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Ithaca 2, Nazareth 0 (A) E8 |
| Rochester 3, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Elmira 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 4, Clarkson 0 (A) |
| St. John Fisher 1, Nazareth 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 2, Oswego 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Alfred 1 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 1, SUNYIT 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 3, Hobart 3, ot (A) |
| Daemen 2, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 1, Utica 0 (A) E8 |
| RIT 4, Nazareth 2 (A) E8 |
| Union 5, Nazareth 2 (A) |
| Nazareth 0, Ithaca 0, ot (A) E8 Tournament, Nazareth advances on penalty kicks, 4-1 |
| Nazareth 1, RIT 1, ot (A) E8 Tournament, Nazareth gains NCAA berth on penalty kicks, 4-2 |
| Brockport 2, Nazareth 0 (at East Rochester HS) NCAA Tournament |
|
| 2006 (Danny Gilbertson, 15-5-3 overall, 3-2-1 Empire 8) |
| Captains: Ed Babcock, Jeremy Bergan |
| Nazareth 2, Geneseo 1, ot (N) Doug May Tournament at RIT |
| Nazareth 3, Washington & Jefferson 1 (N) Doug May Tournament at RIT |
| Nazareth 2, Buffalo State 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Oswego 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Hamilton 1 (H) |
| Ithaca 1, Nazareth 0 (H) E8 |
| Rochester 2, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Elmira 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 4, Fredonia 2 (H) |
| Nazareth 4, St. John Fisher 1 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 5, Daemen 2 (A) |
| Alfred 2, Nazareth 0 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 2, SUNYIT 0 (H) |
| Hobart 2, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Utica 1 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 0, RIT 0, ot (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 3, Union 2, ot (H) |
| Nazareth 1, Ithaca 1, ot (A) E8 Tournament, Nazareth advances on penalty kicks, 5-4 |
| Nazareth 1, RIT 0 (A) E8 Tournament |
| Nazareth 2, Geneseo 0 (H) NCAA Tournament |
| Nazareth 2, Medaille 2, ot (at U.Buffalo) NCAA Tournament, Nazareth advances on penalty kicks, 16-15 |
| Nazareth 1, UC-Santa Cruz 0 (at New Jersey Institute of Technology) NCAA Tournament |
| New York University 1, Nazareth 0 (at New Jersey Institute of Technology) NCAA Tournament |
|
| 2007 (Danny Gilbertson, 8-9-2 overall, 4-3 Empire 8) |
| Captains: Mark Daly, Philip Holmberg, Eli Widrick |
| Nazareth 2, Fredonia 0 (H) Doug May Tournament |
| Geneseo 3, Nazareth 0 (H) Doug May Tournament |
| Nazareth 2, Oswego 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 0, Hamilton 0, ot (A) |
| Nazareth 1, Skidmore 1, ot (A) |
| Union 4, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Rochester 2, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| St. John Fisher 4, Nazareth 0 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 1, Roberts Wesleyan 0, ot (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Alfred 0 (H) E8 |
| Stevens 2, Nazareth 1, ot (A) E8 |
| Utica 3, Nazareth 1 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 2, SUNYIT 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 1, Elmira 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 2, Ithaca 1 (H) E8 |
| Hobart 1, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, RIT 1 (A) E8 |
| Stevens 2, Nazareth 1 (A) E8 Tournament |
| Medaille 1, Nazareth 0 (A) ECAC Tournament |
|
| 2008 (Danny Gilbertson, 7-8-2 overall, 3-3-1 Empire 8) |
| Captains: Mohammed Ahamed, Troy Gotham, Justin Stevens |
| Hobart 1, Nazareth 0, ot (N) Doug May Tournament at RIT |
| Nazareth 11, Gallaudet 1 (N) Doug May Tournament at RIT |
| Oswego 1, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Buffalo State 3, Nazareth 2, ot (H) |
| Nazareth 0, Union 0, ot (H) |
| Rochester 2, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 1, Hamilton 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, SUNYIT 1 (H) |
| St. John Fisher 5, Nazareth 3 (H) E8 |
| Fredonia 4, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 1, Ithaca 1, ot (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 3, Elmira 0 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 4, Keuka 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Utica 2 (H) E8 |
| Stevens 4, Nazareth 1 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 3, Alfred 2 (A) E8 |
| RIT 2, Nazareth 1 (H) |
|
| 2009 (Danny Gilbertson, 11-5-2 overall, 5-0-2 Empire 8) |
| Captains: Mohammed Ahamed, Liam Connolly, Philip Holmberg, Chris Löfgren |
| Brockport 2, Nazareth 0 (H) Doug May Tournament |
| Hobart 4, Nazareth 1 (H) Doug May Tournament |
| Nazareth 3, Buffalo State 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 4, Oswego 0 (A) |
| Fredonia 1, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Hamilton 1 (A) |
| Rochester 4, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 1 Utica 0 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 1, SUNYIT 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 4, Elmira 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 1, Ithaca 1, ot (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 0, Stevens 0, ot (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 2, St. John Fisher 0 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 3, Keuka 2 (A) |
| Nazareth 5, Alfred 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 1, RIT 0 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 2, St. John Fisher 1 (H) E8 Tournament |
| Stevens 2, Nazareth 1 (H) E8 Tournament |
|
| 2010 (Danny Gilbertson, 10-7-2 overall, 6-1 Empire 8) |
| Captains: Liam Connolly, Rikesh Kotak |
| Nazareth 0, Brockport 0, ot (N) Doug May Tournament at RIT, Nazareth advances on penalty kicks, 3-2 |
| RIT 2, Nazareth 1, ot (A) Doug May Tournament at RIT |
| Nazareth 2, Oswego 0 (at Roberts Wesleyan) |
| Messiah 2, Nazareth 1, ot (H) |
| Fredonia 2, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| Hamilton 2, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 1, Rochester 1, ot (A) |
| Nazareth 1, Ithaca 0 (A) E8 |
| Hobart 3, Nazareth 2, ot (A) |
| Nazareth 3, Utica 2 (H) E8 |
| Stevens 4, Nazareth 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 3, Geneseo 2 (H) |
| Nazareth 8, Alfred 0 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 3, St. John Fisher 1 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 4, Buffalo State 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Elmira 0 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 2, RIT 1 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 3, Elmira 1 (H) E8 Tournament |
| Stevens 1, Nazareth 0 (A) E8 Tournament |
|
| 2011 (Danny Gilbertson, 10-6-1 overall, 4-2-0 Empire 8) |
| Captains: Liam Connolly, Sean Dorman, Chris Mitchell |
| Nazareth 4, SUNY Canton 1 (H) Doug May Tournament |
| Nazareth 2, Brockport 1, ot (H) Doug May Tournament |
| Oswego 1, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Fredonia 1, ot (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Utica 1 (A) E8 |
| RIT 1, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Elmira 1, Nazareth 0 (H) E8 |
| Union 2, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Stevens 2, Nazareth 1 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 2, Geneseo 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, St. John Fisher 0 (A) E8 |
| Hobart 1, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 4, Alfred 1 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 1, Buffalo State 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Ithaca 1 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 4, Rensselaer 0 (H) |
| Elmira 2, Nazareth 2, ot (H) E8 Tournament; Elmira advances on penalty kicks, 4-3 |
|
| 2012 (Danny Gilbertson, 7-9-0 overall, 1-5 Empire 8) |
| Captains: Jimmy Gaffney, Shane Mead |
| Nazareth 4, SUNY Canton 2 (N) Doug May Tournament at RIT |
| Nazareth 4, Brockport 2 (N) Doug May Tournament at RIT |
| Nazareth 3, Oswego 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Fredonia 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Utica 1 (H) E8 |
| RIT 2, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Elmira 3, Nazareth 2 (A) E8 |
| Union 3, Nazareth 2, ot (H) |
| Stevens 3, Nazareth 1 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 1, Geneseo 0 (H) |
| Houghton 7, Nazareth 4 (A) |
| St. John Fisher 1, Nazareth 0, ot (H) E8 |
| Hobart 5, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Ithaca 2, Nazareth 0 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 4, Buffalo State 2 (H) |
| Alfred 3, Nazareth 1 (A) E8 |
|
| 2013 (Danny Gilbertson, 6-11-0 overall, 3-3-0 Empire 8) |
| Captains: Ryan Foley, Jimmy Gaffney, Simon Mounsdon |
| Nazareth 5, SUNY Canton 3 (H) Doug May Tournament |
| Brockport 4, Nazareth 1 (H) Doug May Tournament |
| Cortland 2, Nazareth 1, ot (A) |
| Nazareth 3, Oswego 2 (A) |
| Swarthmore 3, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Fredonia 1 (A) |
| Utica 1, Nazareth 0 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 3, Elmira 2 (H) E8 |
| Geneseo 2, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Stevens 4, Nazareth 0 (A) E8 |
| Hobart 6, Nazareth 2 (H) |
| Houghton 3, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 1, St. John Fisher 0 (A) E8 |
| Ithaca 1, Nazareth 0 (H) E8 |
| Buffalo State 5, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 5, Alfred 1 (H) E8 |
| Stevens 5, Nazareth 0 (A) Empire 8 Tournament |
|
| 2014 (Danny Gilbertson, 5-12-0 overall, 3-4-0 Empire 8) |
| Captains: Ryan Foley, James Wheeler |
| Nazareth 3, Allegheny 1 (H) Doug May Tournament |
| Centenary 2, Nazareth 1 (H) Doug May Tournament |
| Nazareth 2, Oswego 0 (H) |
| Skidmore 4, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Fredonia 3, Nazareth 2 (H) |
| Stevens 2, Nazareth 0 (H) E8 |
| RIT 5, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Alfred 5, Nazareth 4 (A) E8 |
| Geneseo 3, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 1, Houghton 0 (A) E8 |
| Hobart 6, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| St. John Fisher 4, Nazareth 2 (H) E8 |
| Bryant & Stratton 2, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Utica 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 5, Elmira 1 (A) E8 |
| Buffalo State 2, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| Ithaca 1, Nazareth 0, ot (A) E8 |
|
| 2015 (Danny Gilbertson, 0-15-1 overall, 0-6-1 Empire 8) |
| Captains: Alessio DeMichele, Kieran McCoy, Brendan Miles |
| Skidmore 3, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Buffalo State 3, Nazareth 0 (H) Doug May Tournament |
| King's, Pa. 3, Nazareth 0 (H) Doug May Tournament |
| Mount St. Mary 2, Nazareth 0 (N) at Plattsburgh Tournament |
| Colby-Sawyer 3, Nazareth 1 (N) at Plattsburgh Tournament |
| Fredonia 3, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Houghton 3, Nazareth 1 (H) E8 |
| RIT 3, Nazareth 2 (H) |
| Utica 6, Nazareth 0 (A) E8 |
| Geneseo 5, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Alfred 4, Nazareth 0 (H) E8 |
| Hobart 4, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Elmira 2, ot (H) E8 |
| Ithaca 3, Nazareth 0 (H) E8 |
| St. John Fisher 1, Nazareth 0 (A) E8 |
| Stevens 6, Nazareth 0 (A) E8 |
|
| 2016 (Matt Tantalo, 6-8-2 overall, 1-4-2 Empire 8) |
| Captains: Alessio DeMichele, Kieran McCoy |
| Nazareth 1, Morrisville State 0 (H) Doug May Tournament |
| Buffalo State 3, Nazareth 0 (H) Doug May Tournament |
| Nazareth 3, D'Youville 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Pitt.-Bradford 0 (A) |
| Fredonia 3, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 1, Alfred 1, ot (A) E8 |
| RIT 2, Nazareth 1, ot (A) |
| Ithaca 1, Nazareth 0 (A) E8 |
| Geneseo 1, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| St. John Fisher 2, Nazareth 1, ot (H) E8 |
| Houghton 4, Nazareth 1 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 3, Alfred State 0 (H) |
| Stevens 1, Nazareth 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 0, Elmira 0, ot (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 5, Cazenovia 2 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Utica 0 (H) E8 |
|
| 2017 (Matt Tantalo, 10-6-1 overall, 5-2-0 Empire 8) |
| Captains: AJ Muoio, Zach Titus, Brian Wilkin |
| Rutgers-Newark 3, Nazareth 0 (H) Doug May Tournament |
| Brockport 2, Nazareth 1 (H) Doug May Tournament |
| Nazareth 3, Cazenovia 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 6, D'Youville 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Fredonia 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Sage 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 0, RIT 0, ot (H) |
| Elmira 2, Nazareth 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 4, Pitt.-Bradford 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Utica 0 (A) E8 |
| Geneseo 1, Nazareth 0, ot (A) |
| Nazareth 1, Alfred 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 5, Alfred State 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 1, St. John Fisher 0, ot (A) E8 |
| Stevens 3, Nazareth 1 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 2, Houghton 1 (H) E8 |
| Sage 2, Nazareth 1, ot (at Stevens) E8 Tournament |
|
| 2018 (Matt Tantalo, 12-7-1 overall, 4-2-1 Empire 8) |
| Captains: AJ Muoio, Zach Titus, Brian Wilkin |
| Brockport 1, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Rensselaer 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Wells 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 3, D'Youville 1 (H) |
| Fredonia 2, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 0, Sage 0, ot (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 3, Pitt.-Bradford 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 1, Elmira 0 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 5, Morrisville 0 (H) |
| Utica 2, Nazareth 1 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 1, St. John Fisher 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 6, Alfred State 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 1, Alfred 0 (A) E8 |
| Geneseo 1, Nazareth 0 (H) |
| Stevens 2, Nazareth 0 (H) E8 |
| SUNY Delhi 3, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 4, Houghton 1 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 5, Hartwick 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 1, Alfred 0 (at Stevens) E8 Tournament |
| Stevens 2, Nazareth 0 (A) E8 Tournament |
|
| 2019 (Matt Tantalo, 14-3-3 overall, 5-0-1 Empire 8) |
| Captains: Game captains |
| Nazareth 4, Bard 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 9, Villa Maria 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Wells 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Alfred State 0 (A) |
| Fredonia 2, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Ithaca 2, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 1, Morrisville 1, ot (A) |
| Nazareth 4, Alfred 1 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 4, Medaille 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Hartwick 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 4, SUNY Delhi 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 1, Sage 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 1, Utica 0 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 1, St. John Fisher 1, ot (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 2, Geneseo 2, ot (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Houghton 1 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 2, Elmira 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 2, Elmira 0 (H) Empire 8 Tournament |
| Nazareth 1, Alfred 0 (H) Empire 8 Tournament |
| Worcester Polytechnic Institute 2, Nazareth 0 (at Tufts) NCAA Tournament |
|
| 2020 (Matt Tantalo, 3-3-0 overall, 3-2-0 Empire 8) |
| Captains: Game captains |
| Nazareth 3, Alfred 0 (A) E8 |
| Russell Sage 2, Nazareth 1, ot (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 1, St. John Fisher 0, ot (H) E8 |
| Houghton 3, Nazareth 0 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 2, Utica 1 (H) E8 |
| St. John Fisher 1, Nazareth 0 (A) Empire 8 Tournament |
|
| 2021 (Matt Tantalo, 13-2-3 overall, 7-0-1 Empire 8) |
| Captains: Colin Brickwood, Sam Smyth, Andrew Vogler, Dante Walters |
| Nazareth 5, Wells 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 0, Brockport 0, 2ot (A) Doug May Tournament |
| RIT 3, Nazareth 1 (A) Doug May Tournament |
| Nazareth 2, SUNY Poly 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 6, Pitt.-Bradford 2 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Alfred 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 9, Hilbert 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Keuka 0 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 2, Fredonia 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 6, Russell Sage 1 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 2, Utica 1 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 1, Elmira 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 1, St. John Fisher 1, 2ot (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 2, Hartwick 1 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 1, Houghton 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 1, St. John Fisher 1, ot (H) Empire 8 Tournament; Nazareth advances on penalty kicks, 4-2 |
| Nazareth 2, Houghton 0 (H) Empire 8 Tournament |
| Cortland 6, Nazareth 1 (A) NCAA Tournament |
|
| 2022 (Matt Tantalo, 7-5-5 overall, 2-2-5 Empire 8) |
| Captains: Sam Smyth, Cuneyt Vardar, Andrew Vogler) |
| Nazareth 7, Allegheny 2 (H) |
| Nazareth 5, Wells 1 (A) |
| SUNY Poly 3, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Brockport 1, Nazareth 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 5, Pitt.-Bradford 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Hartwick 1 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 5, Alfred State 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 0, Houghton 0 (A) E8 |
| Utica 3, Nazareth 2 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 1, Alfred 1 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 3, Russell Sage 1 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 5, Fredonia 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Medaille 3 (H) E8 |
| Keuka 1, Nazareth 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 1, Elmira 1 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 1, St. John Fisher 1 (H) E8 |
| Utica 1, Nazareth 0 (A) Empire 8 Tournament |
|
| 2023 (Matt Tantalo, 10-4-2 overall, 5-2-1 Empire 8) |
| Captains: Matt Bamford, Drew Decker, Michael Yates |
| Nazareth 3, Allegheny 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 4, Morrisville 2 (H) |
| Nazareth 1, SUNY Poly 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Hilbert 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 1, Hobart 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Russell Sage 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 2, Oswego 0 (A) |
| Nazareth 1, Hartwick 0 (A) E8 |
| Utica 1, Nazareth 0 (A) E8 |
| Rochester 2, Nazareth 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Alfred 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 1, Keuka 0 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 4, Houghton 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 1, Elmira 1 (H) E8 |
| St. John Fisher 1, Nazareth 0 (A) E8 |
| Alfred 2, Nazareth 1 (H) Empire 8 Tournament |
|
| 2024 (Matt Tantalo, 10-4-4 overall, 7-1-3 Empire 8) |
| Captains: Drew Decker, Jake Pawlika, Michael Yates |
| Oswego 3, Nazareth 2 (H) |
| Nazareth 9, Hilbert 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 1, Hobart 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Allegheny 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Fredonia 2 (A) |
| Nazareth 5, Hartwick 0 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 1, Alfred 1 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 1, Keuka 0 (H) E8 |
| Rochester 2, Nazareth 1 (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Houghton 1 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 2, Brockport 1 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 1, Russell Sage 1 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 2, Geneseo 1 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 4, Utica 3 (H) E8 |
| Nazareth 0, SUNY Poly 0 (A) E8 |
| Nazareth 4, Elmira 2 (A) E8 |
| St. John Fisher 1, Nazareth 0 (H) E8 |
| Elmira 2, Nazareth 1 (H) Empire 8 Tournament |
|
