| NCAA Tournament | ECAC Tournament | Empire 8 Tournament |
| NCAA Division III Tournament |
| 2023 |
| William Smith 4, Nazareth 1 (A) |
|
| 2022 |
| Calvin 2, Nazareth 0 (at Carnegie Mellon) |
|
| 2021 |
| Scranton 3, Nazareth 0 (A) |
|
| 2016 |
| Nazareth 2, Wittenberg 1 (A) |
| Penn State Berks 1, Nazareth 0 (at Wittenberg) |
|
| 2014 |
| Nazareth 1, Worcester State 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Amherst 2, ot (H) |
| Nazareth advances on penalty kicks, 4-3 |
| Messiah 3, Nazareth 0 (A) |
|
| 2008 |
| Endicott 1, Nazareth 0, ot (H) |
|
| 2006 |
| Montclair State 1, Nazareth 0 (at Elizabethtown, Pa.) |
|
| 2002 |
| Nazareth 3, Grove City 2 (H) |
| William Smith 2, Nazareth 1, pks (A) |
|
| 2001 |
| Nazareth 2, Rochester 1 (H) |
| Union 3, Nazareth 2 (at William Smith) |
|
| 2000 |
| Nazareth 7, Penn State Behrend 1 (H) |
| William Smith 2, Nazareth 1 (A) |
|
| 1999 |
| Nazareth 1, Oneonta 0, 2ot (at William Smith) |
| Nazareth 2, William Smith 0 (A) |
| Williams 2, Nazareth 0 (H) |
|
| 1998 |
| Rochester 1, Nazareth 0, 3ot (H) |
|
| 1997 |
| Nazareth 3, Oneonta 2, 3ot (H) |
| Rochester 3, Nazareth 2 (at William Smith) |
|
| ECAC Tournament |
| 2007 |
| Nazareth 7, Keuka 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 1, Fredonia 0, ot (at Brockport) |
| Nazareth 1, Brockport 0 (A) |
|
| 2005 |
| Nazareth 1, Fredonia 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, Geneseo 1 (H) |
|
| 2003 |
| Rochester 4, Nazareth 0 (H) |
|
| 1996 |
| Nazareth 4, College of Notre Dame, Md. 0 (H) |
| Rensselaer 2, Nazareth 1 (A) |
|
| Empire 8 Conference Tournament |
| 2024 |
| Nazareth 1, Russell Sage 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 0, Brockport 0, ot (A) |
| Nazareth advances on penalty kicks, 7-6 |
| Geneseo 1, Nazareth 0 (A) |
|
| 2023 |
| Nazareth 3, Russell Sage 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, St. John Fisher 0 (H) |
|
| 2022 |
| Nazareth 2, Russell Sage 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 1, Utica 0 (H) |
|
| 2021 |
| Nazareth 3, Hartwick 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 3, St. John Fisher 0 (H) |
|
| 2020* |
| Nazareth 1, Utica 1, ot (H) |
| Utica advances on penalty kicks, 4-2 |
| *game played in 2021 due to COVID-19 pandemic |
|
| 2019 |
| Hartwick 1, Nazareth 0 (A) |
|
| 2017 |
| Nazareth 0, Stevens 0, ot (at Hartwick) |
| Stevens advances on penalty kicks, 3-2 |
|
| 2016 |
| Ithaca 1, Nazareth 0, ot (at Stevens) |
|
| 2015 |
| Ithaca 2, Nazareth 1 (at Stevens) |
|
| 2014 |
| Nazareth 2, Stevens 0 (at Ithaca) |
| Nazareth 0, Ithaca 0, ot (A) |
| Teams declared E8 co-champs; Nazareth gains NCAA berth on pks, 4-3 |
|
| 2013 |
| Nazareth 3, Stevens 1 (at Ithaca) |
| Ithaca 3, Nazareth 1 (A) |
|
| 2012 |
| Nazareth 1, Stevens 1, ot (at Ithaca) |
| Nazareth advances on penalty kicks, 3-1 |
| Nazareth 0, Ithaca 0, ot (A) |
| Teams declared E8 co-champs; Ithaca gains NCAA berth on pks, 3-2 |
|
| 2011 |
| Nazareth 3, Ithaca 1 (at Stevens) |
| Stevens 2, Nazareth 0 (A) |
|
| 2010 |
| Nazareth 2, RIT 0 (H) |
| Stevens 2, Nazareth 1 (H) |
|
| 2009 |
| Nazareth 3, St. John Fisher 0 (at Ithaca) |
| Ithaca 2, Nazareth 0 (A) |
|
| 2008 |
| Nazareth 3, RIT 1 (at Ithaca) |
| Ithaca 5, Nazareth 0 (A) |
|
| 2007 |
| Nazareth 0, Stevens 0, ot (A) |
| Nazareth advances on penalty kicks, 4-3 |
| Ithaca 2, Nazareth 1 (A) |
|
| 2006 |
| Nazareth 1, Ithaca 0, ot (A) |
| Nazareth 2, Utica 1, ot (A) |
|
| 2005 |
| Nazareth 4, St. John Fisher 3 (H) |
| Nazareth 0, Ithaca 0, ot (H) |
| Teams declared E8 co-champs; Ithaca gains NCAA berth on pks, 5-4 |
|
| 2004 |
| Nazareth 6, Elmira 0 (H) |
| Nazareth 2, Ithaca 2, ot (A) |
| Teams declared E8 co-champs; Ithaca gains NCAA berth on pks, 9-8 |
|
| 2003 |
| Nazareth 5, RIT 1 (H) |
| Nazareth 0, Ithaca 0, ot (H) |
| Teams declared E8 co-champs; Ithaca gains NCAA berth on pks, 4-3 |
|
| 2002 |
| Nazareth 5, Elmira 0 (at Ithaca) |
| Nazareth 1, Ithaca 0, pks (A) |
| Teams declared E8 co-champs; Nazareth gains NCAA berth on pks, 4-2 |
