| |
| 1999 |
| Jake Coon, jr. goalie (first team) |
| Joel DePietro, sr. midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Dennis Foley, sr. attackman (honorable mention) |
| Eric Goodberlet, soph. attackman (first team) |
| Chris Nadelen, sr. midfielder (first team) |
| John Nevin, sr. midfielder (second team) |
| Mark Sovie, soph. defenseman (second team) |
| Ryan Trombley, jr. defenseman (second team) |
| Scott Nelson, Coach of the Year |
| |
| 1998 |
| Adam Civalier, sr. midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Jake Coon, soph. goalie (second team) |
| Dennis Foley, jr. attackman (second team) |
| Ryan McDermott, sr. midfielder (first team, Player of the Year) |
| Carmine Peluso, sr. defenseman (second team) |
| Billy Serino, jr. midfielder (second team) |
| Ryan Trombley, soph. defensive midfielder (first team) |
| Scott Nelson, Coach of the Year |
| |
| 1997 |
| Tom Fritz, sr. defensive midfielder (first team) |
| Dan Garrett, sr. defenseman (first team) |
| Brandon Piccarreto, jr. defenseman (first team) |
| Brent Rothfuss, sr. midfielder (first team, Player of the Year) |
| Marcos Santana, sr. defenseman (second team) |
| |
| 1996 |
| Trent Brown, jr. attackman (second team) |
| Tom Fritz, jr. defensive midfielder (second team) |
| Dan Garrett, jr. defenseman (second team) |
| Terry Goetz, sr. midfielder (second team) |
| Brandon Piccarreto, soph. defenseman (first team) |
| Neal Powless, sr. attackman (first team) |
| Brent Rothfuss, jr. midfielder (first team) |
| Marcos Santana, jr. defenseman (first team) |
| Ben Wineburg, sr. goalie (first team, Player of the Year) |
