| 1991 |
| Joe Alden, soph. defenseman (second team) |
| Peter Burkin, sr. defenseman (second team) |
| Tim Cox, jr. attackman (first team) |
| Greg Gebhardt, jr. goalie (first team) |
| Carl Jutzin, jr. midfielder (second team) |
| Marty Kelly, jr. attackman (first team, Player of the Year) |
| Jake Lazore, sr. midfielder (first team) |
| Dave Pratt, jr. defenseman (second team) |
| Petre Riley, jr. defensive midfielder (first team) |
| Scott Nelson, Coach of the Year |
|
| 1990 |
| Greg Gebhardt, soph. goalie (second team) |
| Marty Kelly, soph. attackman (first team) |
| Rich Kilgour, soph. midfielder (first team) |
| John McAuliffe, sr. defenseman (first team) |
| Bill Meagher, sr. midfielder (second team) |
|
| 1989 |
| Bill Atkinson, sr. attackman (first team) |
| Pete Burkin, soph. defenseman (second team) |
| Bill Coons, sr. attackman (first team, Player of the Year) |
| Tom Coons, sr. midfielder (first team) |
| Gerry Gutchess, sr. midfielder (first team) |
| Bob Kuzdzal, sr. defenseman (first team) |
| Jerome Lazore, jr. midfielder (first team) |
| John McAuliffe, jr. defenseman (first team) |
| Dana Ryan, jr. goalie (second team) |
|
| 1988 |
| Bill Atkinson, jr. attackman (second team) |
| Bill Coons, jr. attackman (first team, Player of the Year) |
| Tom Coons, jr. midfielder (first team) |
| Pat Gannon, sr. defenseman (second team) |
| Rocky Garofalo, sr. goalie (first team) |
| Gerry Gutchess, jr. midfielder (second team) |
| Jerome Lazore, soph. midfielder (first team) |
| John McAuliffe, soph. defenseman (first team) |
| Scott Nelson (Coach of the Year) |
