| 2026 |
| Louis Cogliandro, sr. midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Matt Farrington, sr. attackman (honorable mention) |
| Luke Suchyna, sr. short-stick defensive midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Nick Hinck, soph. defenseman (honorable mention) |
|
| 2025 |
| Jakob Denkenberger, sr. face-off specialist (honorable mention) |
| Quinn McKercher, gr. attackman (honorable mention) |
|
| 2024 |
| Quinn Conroy, sr. midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Quinn McKercher, sr. attackman (honorable mention) |
|
| 2023 |
| Quinn McKercher, jr. attackman (honorable mention) |
|
| 2022 |
| Brett Randall, gr. attackman (third team) |
| Griffin Randall, sr. defenseman (honorable mention) |
| Jon Roth, sr. midfielder (honorable mention) |
|
| 2021 |
| Owen Gonzalez, sr. short-stick defensive midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Jeremy Jacob, sr. attackman (honorable mention) |
| Jon Roth, jr. midfielder (honorable mention) |
|
| 2020 |
| Tim Vinton, sr. face-off specialist (Inside Lacrosse honorable mention) |
|
| 2017 |
| Hunter Burdick, sr. midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Seth DeLisle, jr. face-off specialist (second team) |
| Luke Longo, sr. short-stick defensive midfielder (honorable mention) |
|
| 2016 |
| Troy Haefele, sr. attackman (honorable mention) |
| Luke Longo, jr. short-stick defensive midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Matt O'Neill, sr. midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Luke Wooters, sr. attackman (second team) |
|
| 2015 |
| Jerry Chasteen, sr. defenseman (third team) |
| Troy Haefele, jr. attackman (honorable mention) |
| Luke Longo, soph. short-stick defensive midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Drew Simoneau, sr. face-off specialist (first team) |
| Luke Wooters, jr. attackman (second team) |
|
| 2014 |
| Drew Simoneau, jr. face-off specialist (third team) |
|
| 2013 |
| Collin Clark, jr. midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Chris Peterson, sr. short-stick defensive midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Drew Simoneau, soph. face-off specialist (honorable mention) |
| Luke Wooters, fr. attackman (honorable mention) |
|
| 2012 |
| C.J. Estes, sr. attackman (honorable mention) |
|
| 2011 |
| Scott Castle, sr. midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Mitchel Frey, sr. defenseman (honorable mention) |
| Joe Jacobs-Ferderbar, sr. attackman (honorable mention) |
| Brian Orr, sr. defenseman (honorable mention) |
|
| 2010 |
| Kyle Brown, sr. defensive midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Scott Castle, jr. midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Mark DeCirce, sr. attackman (third team) |
| Joe Jacobs-Ferderbar, jr. attackman (honorable mention) |
|
| 2009 |
| Scott Castle, soph. midfielder (honorable mention) |
|
| 2008 |
| Aaron Civalier, sr. midfielder (third team) |
|
| 2007 |
| Chad Amidon, sr. midfielder (first team) |
| Ryan Conley, sr. defenseman (honorable mention) |
| Ryan Hotaling, sr. attackman (first team) |
|
| 2006 |
| Bryan Adams, sr. midfielder (third team) |
| Ryan Hotaling, jr. attackman (third team) |
| Jeff Mangini, sr. defensive midfielder (honorable mention) |
|
| 2005 |
| Bryan Adams, jr. midfielder (second team) |
| Chris Cimini, sr. defenseman (second team) |
| Alex Civalier, jr. goalie (honorable mention) |
| Bryan Coon, sr. attackman (honorable mention) |
| Francis Donald, soph. defensive midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Ryan Hotaling, soph. attackman (first team) |
| Gordon Quonce, sr. defenseman (honorable mention) |
|
| 2004 |
| Bryan Adams, soph. midfielder (third team) |
| Brandon Brown, sr. attackman (honorable mention) |
| Chris Cimini, jr. defenseman (honorable mention) |
| Bryan Coon, jr. attackman (honorable mention) |
| Brian Navarra, sr. midfielder (honorable mention) |
| T.J. Rogers, sr. midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Justin Wahl, sr. attackman (honorable mention) |
|
| 2003 |
| Bryan Coon, soph. attackman (honorable mention) |
| Matt Kent, sr. defensive midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Jim Quackenbush, sr. midfielder (honorable mention) |
|
| 2002 |
| Kevin Flanagan, sr. defenseman (honorable mention) |
| Jarod Koopman, sr. midfielder (third team) |
| P.J. Rosecrans, sr. midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Craig Sleeman, sr. defensive midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Ethan Sleeman, sr. defenseman (honorable mention) |
|
| 2001 |
| Rob Carroll, sr. goalie (honorable mention) |
| Jim Cianfrocca, sr. attackman (honorable mention) |
| Eric Goodberlet, sr. midfielder (first team) |
| Jarod Koopman, jr. midfielder (honorable mention) |
| P.J. Rosecrans, jr. midfielder (third team) |
| Ethan Sleeman, jr. defenseman (second team) |
| Mark Sovie, sr. defenseman (first team) |
| Al Terilli, jr. midfielder (third team) |
|
| 2000 |
| Jake Coon, sr. goalie (first team) |
| Chris Corcoran, sr. defensive midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Eric Goodberlet, jr. midfielder (second team) |
| Jeff Keys, sr. attackman (honorable mention) |
| Kevin Leonard, sr. defenseman (honorable mention) |
| P.J. Rosecrans, soph. Midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Mark Sovie, jr. defenseman (second team) |
| Al Terilli, jr. midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Ryan Trombley, sr. defenseman (second team) |
|
| 1999 |
| Jake Coon, jr. goalie (third team) |
| Eric Goodberlet, soph. attackman (honorable mention) |
| Chris Nadelen, sr. midfielder (honorable mention) |
| John Nevin, sr. midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Billy Serino, sr. midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Ryan Trombley, jr. defenseman (honorable mention) |
|
| 1998 |
| Adam Civalier, sr. midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Jake Coon, soph. goalie (first team) |
| Dennis Foley, jr. attackman (third team) |
| Ryan McDermott, sr. midfielder (first team) |
| Carmine Peluso, sr. defenseman (second team) |
| Billy Serino, jr. midfielder (second team) |
|
| 1997 |
| Trent Brown, sr. attackman (third team) |
| Jake Coon, fr. goalie (honorable mention) |
| Dan Garrett, sr. defenseman (first team) |
| Tom Fritz, sr. defensive midfielder (first team) |
| Ryan McDermott, jr. midfielder (second team) |
| Brandon Piccarreto, jr. defenseman (first team) |
| Brent Rothfuss, sr. midfielder (first team) |
| Marcos Santana, sr. defenseman (second team) |
| Joe Spada, sr. attackman (honorable mention) |
|
| 1996 |
| John Burdett, sr. midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Tom Fritz, jr. defensive midfielder (second team) |
| Dan Garrett, jr. defenseman (third team) |
| Terry Goetz, sr. midfielder (second team) |
| Ryan McDermott, soph. midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Brandon Piccarreto, soph. defenseman (first team) |
| Neal Powless, sr. attackman (second team) |
| Brent Rothfuss, jr. midfielder (first team) |
| Marcos Santana, jr. defenseman (second team) |
| Ben Wineburg, sr. goalie (first team) |
|
| 1995 |
| Tom Fritz, soph. defenseman (honorable mention) |
| Ed Geary, sr. attackman (third team) |
| Brian Majczak, sr. midfielder (second team) |
| Neal Powless, jr. attackman (first team) |
| Chuck Roberts, sr. defenseman (second team) |
| Brent Rothfuss, soph. midfielder (second team) |
| Marcos Santana, soph. defenseman (honorable mention) |
| Ben Wineburg, jr. goalie (second team) |
|
| 1994 |
| Cam Bomberry, sr. midfielder (second team) |
| Jeremy Hollenbeck, sr. midfielder (first team) |
| Pat Metzler, jr. attackman (third team) |
| Sean O'Rourke, sr. goalie (honorable mention) |
| Rich Petersen, sr. defenseman (third team) |
| Neal Powless, soph. attackman (honorable mention) |
| Tony Wallace, sr. defenseman (honorable mention) |
|
| 1993 |
| Joe Alden, sr. defenseman (third team) |
| Cam Bomberry, jr. midfielder (third team) |
| Jeremy Hollenbeck, jr. midfielder (second team) |
| Kevin Kaffl, sr. goalie (third team) |
| Pat Metzler, soph. attackman (third team) |
| Rich Petersen, jr. defenseman (honorable mention) |
| Brian Silcott, sr. midfielder (first team) |
|
| 1992 |
| Joe Alden, jr. defenseman (second team) |
| Cam Bomberry, soph. midfielder (third team) |
| Ronnie Davis, sr. midfielder (first team) |
| Greg Gebhardt, sr. goalie (first team) |
| Carl Jutzin, sr. midfielder (third team) |
| Marty Kelly, sr. attackman (first team) |
| Dave Pratt, sr. defenseman (first team) |
| Pete Riley, sr. defensive midfielder (second team) |
| Brian Silcott, jr. midfielder (second team) |
|
| 1991 |
| Joe Alden, soph. defenseman (honorable mention) |
| Tim Cox, jr. attackman (honorable mention) |
| Greg Gebhardt, jr. goalie (honorable mention) |
| Marty Kelly, jr. attackman (first team) |
| Jake Lazore, sr. midfielder (first team) |
| Dave Pratt, jr. defenseman (first team) |
| Peter Riley, jr. defensive midfielder (second team) |
|
| 1990 |
| Carl Jutzin, soph. midfielder (third team) |
| Marty Kelly, soph. attackman (honorable mention) |
| John McAuliffe, sr. defenseman (honorable mention) |
|
| 1989 |
| Bill Atkinson, sr. attackman (third team) |
| Bill Coons, sr. attackman (first team) |
| Gerry Gutchess, sr. midfielder (second team) |
| Bob Kuzdzal, sr. defensive midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Jerome Lazore, jr. midfielder (third team) |
| John McAuliffe, jr. defenseman (third team) |
|
| 1988 |
| Bill Coons, jr. attackman (third team) |
| Pat Gannon, sr. defensive midfielder (honorable mention) |
| Gerry Gutchess, jr. midfielder (honorable mention) |
