| NCAA Division III All-Americans |
| 2008 |
| Nick Stenuf, gr. (19th place) |
|
| NCAA National Qualifiers |
| 2008 |
| Nick Stenuf, gr. |
|
| 2007 |
| Brendan Epstein, sr. |
| Nick Stenuf, sr. |
|
| NCAA Division III Niagara Region all-stars |
| 2023 |
| Nathan Bowers, gr. |
| Cade Eells, jr. |
|
| 2022 |
| Nathan Bowers, sr. |
|
| 2021 |
| Nathan Bowers, jr. |
| Nathan McNally, jr. |
|
| NCAA Division III Atlantic Region all-stars |
| 2006 |
| Nick Stenuf, jr. |
|
| NYSCTC all-stars |
| 2005 |
| Brendan Epstein, soph. (third team) |
|
| Empire 8 Conference Champions |
| 2007 |
| Brendan Epstein, sr. |
|
| Empire 8 Conference All-Stars |
| 2024 |
| Joe Cataldo, jr. (Sportsman of the Year) |
| Cade Eells, sr. (second team) |
|
| 2023 |
| Antonio Benitez, soph. (second team) |
| Nathan Bowers, gr. (second team) |
| Gabe Dauerheim, fr. (Sportsman of the Year) |
| Cade Eells, jr. (first team, co-Runner of the Year) |
| Ethan Glashauser, sr. (third team, Torchbearer Award winner) |
| Connor Jackson, soph. (second team) |
| Ethan Kenyon, jr. (first team) |
|
| 2022 |
| Antonio Benitez, fr. (second team, Sportsman of the Year) |
| Nathan Bowers, sr. (first team) |
| Cade Eells, soph. (first team) |
| Joey Everts, fr. (first team, Rookie of the Year) |
| Connor Jackson, fr. (third team) |
| Ethan Kenyon, soph. (second team) |
| Nathan McNally, sr. (second team) |
| Matt Reimann, jr. (first team, Torchbearer Award winner) |
| Lucas Sharron, sr. (third team) |
| Kenny Williams, jr. (third team) |
| James Goss, Coach of the Year |
|
| 2021 |
| Nathan Bowers, jr. (first team, Sportsman of the Year) |
| Michael Brown, gr. (third team) |
| Cade Eells, fr. (first team, Rookie of the Year) |
| Nathan McNally, jr. (first team) |
| Matt Reimann, soph. (second team) |
| Jake Suddaby, sr. (third team) |
| Lucas Sharron, jr. (third team) |
| Josh Tomaka, sr. (second team) |
|
| Kenny Williams, soph. (second team) |
| James Goss, Coach of the Year |
|
| 2020* |
| Nathan Bowers, soph. (first team) |
| Michael Brown, sr. (first team) |
| Christopher Celecki, sr. (second team) |
| Ethan Glashauser, fr. (second team, Sportsman of the Year) |
| Nathan McNally, soph. (first team) |
| Matt Reimann, fr. (first tream) |
| Jake Suddaby, jr. (second team) |
| Josh Tomaka, jr. (first team) |
| Kenny Williams, fr. (second team) |
| James Goss, Coach of the Year |
| *season contested in 2021 |
|
| 2019 |
| Nathan Bowers, fr. (second team, Sportsman of the Year) |
| Michael Brown, jr. (second team) |
| Christopher Celecki, jr. (first team) |
| Nathan McNally, fr. (first team, Rookie of the Year) |
| Jake Suddaby, soph. (second team) |
| Josh Tomaka, soph. (second team) |
|
| 2018 |
| Christopher Celecki, soph. (first team) |
| Andrew Gwynn, sr. (second team) |
| Patrick Healy, fr. (Sportsman of the Year) |
|
| 2017 |
| Michael Brown, fr. (Sportsman of the Year) |
| Christopher Celecki, fr. (second team) |
| Devyn Chase, fr. (second team) |
|
| 2016 |
| Tom Lannon, sr. (Sportsman of the Year) |
|
| 2015 |
| Jacob Cuyler, fr. (Sportsman of the Year) |
|
| 2014 |
| Patrick Neureuter, jr. (Sportsman of the Year) |
|
| 2013 |
| Zack Lafaver, sr. (Sportsman of the Year) |
|
| 2012 |
| Pete Fekete, sr. (first team) |
| Josh Strough, sr. (Sportsman of the Year) |
|
| 2011 |
| Tim Rutan, sr. (Sportsman of the Year) |
|
| 2010 |
| Matt Morales, sr. (first team, Sportsman of the Year) |
|
| 2009 |
| Tim Rutan, so. (Sportsman of the Year) |
|
| 2008 |
| Robby Castor, sr. (second team, Sportsman of the Year) |
| Nick Stenuf, gr. (first team) |
|
| 2007 |
| Brendan Epstein, sr. (first team, Runner of the Meet) |
| Aaron Sirtoli, sr. (first team) |
| Nick Stenuf, sr. (first team) |
|
| 2006 |
| Brendan Epstein, jr. (second team, Sportsman of the Year) |
| Aaron Sirtoli, jr. (second team) |
| Nick Stenuf, jr. (first team, Rookie of the Year) |
|
| 2005 |
| Brendan Epstein, soph. (first team, Sportsman of the Year) |
| Pat Hughes, soph. (first team) |
|
| 2004 |
| Brendan Epstein, fr. (first team, Rookie of the Year) |
| Pat Hughes, fr. (second team) |
|
|
| Team MVPÂ |
| 2008 - Nick Stenuf |
| 2007 - Brendan Epstein |
| 2006 - Nick Stenuf |
| 2005 - Brendan Epstein |
| 2004 - Brendan Epstein |
| 2003 - David Allen |
|
| Coaches Award |
| 2008 - Tim Rutan |
| 2007 - Matt Morales |
| 2006 - Jon Bates |
| 2005 - Pat Hughes |
| 2004 - Pat Hughes |
| 2003 - Larry DiCesare |
|
| Captains Award |
| 2008 - Matt Morales |
| 2007 - Nick Stenuf |
| 2006 - Chirs Freeman |
| 2005 - Kiel Sick |
| 2004 - Kiel Sick |
| 2003 - Greg McMurray |
