| NCAA Division III All-Americans |
| 2021 |
| Sidney Taylor, sr. (1-meter diving) |
| Sidney Taylor, sr. (3-meter diving) |
|
| 1985 |
| Brian Laible, sr. (1-meter diving) |
|
| NAIA All-Americans |
| 1983 |
| Dave Bergeman, sr. (1-meter diving) |
|
| 1982 |
| Dave Bergeman, jr. (1-meter diving) |
| Dave Bergeman, jr. (3-meter diving) |
| Rick Carvotta, sr. (100 backstroke) |
| Rick Carvotta, sr. (200 backstroke) |
| Joe Farleo, fr. (100 butterfly) |
|
| 1981 |
| Rick Carvotta, jr. (100 backstroke) |
| Rick Carvotta, jr. (200 backstroke) |
|
| Empire 8 Conference All-Stars |
| 2025 |
| Adam DelGrand, sr. (Sportsman of the Year) |
| Ryan Hough, gr. first team (200 freestyle) |
|
| 2024 |
| Cameron Fairley, sr. (Sportsman of the Year) |
| Cameron Fairley, sr. second team (200 freestyle) |
| Cameron Fairley, sr. second team (500 freestyle) |
| Ryan Hough, sr. first team (50 freestyle) |
| Ryan Hough, sr. first team (100 freestyle) |
| Ryan Hough, sr. first team (200 freestyle) |
| 200 freestyle relay (Cameron Fairley, William Danaher, Adam DelGrand, Ryan Hough) first team |
| 400 freestyle relay (Cameron Fairley, William Danaher, Adam DelGrand, Ryan Hough) second team |
| 800 freestyle relay (Ryan Hough, Kai D'Alessandro, Adam DelGrand, Cameron Fairley) second team |
|
| 2023 |
| Kai D'Alessandro, jr. second team (1,650 freestyle) |
| Kai D'Alessandro, jr. second team (400 IM) |
| Cameron Fairley, jr. second team (500 freestyle) |
| Ryan Hough, jr. first team (50 freestyle) |
| Ryan Hough, jr. first team (100 freestyle) |
| Ryan Hough, jr. second team (200 freestyle) |
| Ryan Hough, jr. (Sportsman of the Year) |
| 200 freestyle relay (Cameron Fairley, William Danaher, Adam DelGrand, Ryan Hough) second team |
| 400 freestyle relay (Cameron Fairley, William Danaher, Adam DelGrand, Ryan Hough) second team |
| 800 freestyle (Cameron Fairley, Kai D'Alessandro, Dylan Long, Ryan Hough) first team |
| 400 medley relay (Cameron Fairley, Keagen Winkky, Adam DelGrand, Ryan Hough) second team |
|
| 2022 |
| Kai D'Alessandro, soph. first team (1,650 freestyle) |
| Cameron Fairley, soph. first team (500 freestyle) |
| Cameron Fairley, soph. second team (1,650 freestyle) |
| Cameron Fairley, soph. (Sportsman of the Year) |
| Tom Griffin, sr. second team (50 freestyle) |
| Tom Griffin, sr. first team (100 backstroke) |
| Ryan Hough, soph. first team (100 freestyle) |
| Ryan Hough, soph. second team (200 freestyle) |
| Mathew Ryan, jr. Torchbearer Award |
| Marco Salvatore, sr. first team (400 IM) |
| Jacob Smith, fr. Diver of the Meet / Diver of the Year |
| Jacob Smith, fr. first team (1-meter diving) |
| Jacob Smith, fr. first team (3-meter diving) |
| 200 freestyle relay (Tom Griffin, Joey Knapp, Sean Payrot, Ryan Hough) first team |
| 400 freestyle relay (Tom Griffin, Joey Knapp, Sean Payrot, Ryan Hough) second team |
| 800 freestyle relay (Dylan Long, Joey Knapp, Cameron Fairley, Ryan Hough) first team |
| 200 medley relay (Tom Griffin, Chad Buccella, Marco Salvatore, Sean Payrot) second team |
| 400 medley relay (Tom Griffin, Chad Buccella, Dylan Long, Ryan Hough) second team |
| Chris Heckman, co-Coaching Staff of the Year |
|
| 2020 |
| Luca Biagiotti, jr. first team (100 butterfly) |
| Tom Griffin, soph. second team (50 freestyle) |
| Tom Griffin, soph. second team (100 freestyle) |
| Tom Griffin, soph. first team (100 backstroke) |
| John Koch, jr. Swimmer of the Meet / Swimmer of the Year |
| John Koch, jr. first team (200 butterfly) |
| John Koch, jr. first team (200 IM) |
| John Koch, jr. first team (400 IM) |
| Dylan Long, fr. co-Rookie of the Year |
| Dylan Long, fr. first team (200 freestyle) |
| Dylan Long, fr. first team (500 freestyle) |
| Dylan Long, fr. first team (1,650 freestyle) |
| Connor McCabe, sr. (Sportsman of the Year) |
| Sidney Taylor, jr. Diver of the Meet / Diver of the Year |
| Sidney Taylor, jr. first team (1-meter diving) |
| Sidney Taylor, jr. first team (3-meter diving) |
| 200 freestyle relay (Tom Griffin, Mark Dunkelberg, Sean Payrot, Matt Corona) first team |
| 400 freestyle relay (Tom Griffin, Mark Dunkelberg, Luca Bagiotti, Matt Corona) first team |
| 800 freestyle relay (Luca Biagiotti, Joey Knapp, John Koch, Dylan Long) first team |
| 200 medley relay (Tom Griffin, John Koch, Luca Biagiotti, Mark Dunkelberg) first team |
| 400 medley relay (Tom Griffin, John Koch, Luca Biagiotti, Matt Corona) first team |
| Scott Whitbeck, Coach of the Year |
|
| 2019 |
| Luca Biagiotti, soph. second team (200 butterfly) |
| Robert Draper, sr. first team (500 freestyle) |
| Robert Draper, sr. second team (1650 freestyle) |
| Seth Farrand, soph. first team (50 freestyle) |
| Seth Farrand, soph. first team (100 freestyle) |
| Tom Griffin, fr. Rookie of the Meet |
| Tom Griffin, fr. first team (100 backstroke) |
| Tom Griffin, fr. second team (50 freestyle) |
| John Koch, soph. first team (200 butterfly) |
| John Koch, soph. second team (400 IM) |
| Sidney Taylor, soph. second team (3-meter diving) |
| 200 freestyle relay (Tom Griffin, Mark Dunkelberg, Seth Farrand, Luca Biagiotti) first team |
| 200 medley relay (Tom Griffin, Rob Coatsworth, Seth Farrand, Mark Dunkelberg) first team |
| 400 freestyle relay (Tom Griffin, Mark Dunkelberg, Seth Farrand, Luca Biagiotti) second team |
| 400 medley relay (Tom Griffin, Rob Coatsworth, John Koch, Seth Farrand) second team |
| 800 freestyle relay (Robert Draper, John Koch, Rob Coatsworth, Luca Biagiotti) second team |
|
| 2018 |
| Gannon Connors, sr. second team (100 backstroke) |
| Robert Draper, jr. first team (1,650 freestyle) |
| Robert Draper, jr. second team (400 IM) |
| Seth Farrand, fr. Swimmer of the Meet |
| Seth Farrand, fr. Rookie of the Meet |
| Seth Farrand, fr. first team (50 freestyle) |
| Seth Farrand, fr. first team (100 freestyle) |
| Seth Farrand, fr. first team (100 backstroke) |
| John Koch, fr. first team (200 butterfly) |
| Alex LaPoint, sr. (Sportsman of the Year) |
| Alex LaPoint, sr. second team (200 backstroke) |
| Alex LaPoint, sr. second team (200 IM) |
| Alex LaPoint, sr. first team (400 IM) |
| Sidney Taylor, fr. second team (1-meter diving) |
| Sidney Taylor, fr. second team (3-meter diving) |
| 200 medley relay (Gannon Connors, Rob Coatsworth, John Koch, Seth Farrand) first team |
| 400 medley relay (Gannon Connors, Rob Coatsworth, John Koch, Seth Farrand) second team |
| 200 freestyle relay (Seth Farrand, Gannon Connors, Rob Coatsworth, Mark Dunkelberg) second team |
| 400 freestyle relay (Gannon Connors, Alex LaPoint, Luca Biagiotti, Seth Farrand) second team |
| 800 freestyle relay (Alex LaPoint, Andrew Battaglia, Connor McCabe, Robert Draper) second team |
|
| 2017 |
| Zachary Fink, jr. second team (1-meter diving) |
| Alex LaPoint, jr. second team (200 backstroke) |
| Alex LaPoint, jr. first team (200 IM) |
| Alex LaPoint, jr. second team (400 IM) |
| Declan Lyons, sr. (Sportsman of the Year) |
| 800 freestyle relay (Alex LaPoint, Andrew Battaglia, Connor McCabe, Robert Draper) second team |
|
| 2016 |
| Dan Burke, sr. first team (100 backstroke) |
| Dan Burke, sr. second team (200 backstroke) |
| Andrew Haack, jr. (Sportsman of the Year) |
| Alex LaPoint, soph. second team (200 breaststroke) |
| Alex LaPoint, soph. first team (400 IM) |
|
| 2015 |
| Dan Burke, jr. second team (100 backstroke) |
| Andrew Closson, fr. second team (1-meter diving) |
| Andrew Closson, fr. second team (3-meter diving) |
| Rob Ramos, jr. (Sportsman of the Year) |
|
| 2014 |
| Dan Burke, soph. second team (200 backstroke) |
| Bryan Geary, sr. (Sportsman of the Year) |
| Jeff Green, soph. second team (1-meter diving) |
| Jeff Green, soph. second team (3-meter diving) |
|
| 2013 |
| Patrick Monachino, sr. (Sportsman of the Year) |
|
| 2012 |
| Bryan Geary, soph. (Sportsman of the Year) |
|
| 2011 |
| Ryan Dygert, fr. (Sportsman of the Year) |
|
| 2010 |
| Eric Lenhardt, sr. (Sportsman of the Year) |
| Jacob Kline, fr. first team (100 butterfly) |
|
| 2009 |
| Jeff Dick, soph. (Sportsman of the Year) |
| Mike Fritz, sr. second team (200 backstroke) |
|
| 2002 |
| Josh Nellist, sr. second team (200 IM) |
| Josh Nellist, sr. second team (200 butterfly) |
