| NCAA Division III Indoor All-Americans |
| 2024 |
| Kaleb Luton, gr. 60-meter hurdles (11th place) |
|
| 2016 |
| Luis Rivera, sr. 35-pound weight throw (first place, National Champion) |
|
| 2015 |
| Luis Rivera, jr. 35-pound weight throw (sixth place) |
|
| 2008 |
| Nick Stenuf, sr. 800-meter run (fourth place) |
|
| 2006 |
| Nick Stenuf, soph. 800-meter run (sixth place) |
|
| NCAA Niagara Region Indoor all-stars |
| 2025 |
| Cade Eells, sr. distance medley relay |
| Cole Hastings, soph. distance medley relay |
| Graeden Heichberger, fr. shot put |
| Ethan Kenyon, sr. distance medley relay |
| Ben Lewis, sr. distance medley relay |
| Jack Pomykaj, jr. heptathlon |
|
| 2024 |
| Kaleb Luton, gr. 60-meter hurdles |
| James Goss, Coach of the Year |
|
| 2023 |
| Kaleb Luton, sr. 60-meter hurdles |
|
| 2022 |
| Kaleb Luton, jr. 60-meter hurdles |
| Christopher Perez, sr. 35-pound weight throw |
|
| NCAA Atlantic Region Indoor all-stars |
| 2016 |
| Luis Rivera, sr. 35-pound weight throw |
| Tom Sippie, sr. 400-meter dash |
| 1600-meter relay (Matt Battaglia, Nick LaBarbera, Michael-Jordan Morris, Tom Sippie) |
|
| ECAC Indoor Champions |
| 2016 |
| Luis Rivera, sr. 35-pound weight throw |
|
| 2014 |
| Jake Lafaver, sr. 800-meter run |
|
| 2008 |
| Robby Castor, jr. 1,000-meter run |
| Nick Stenuf, sr. 800-meter run |
| Brandon Wheeler, jr. 400-meter dash |
|
| 2006 |
| Nick Stenuf, soph. 800-meter run |
|
| NYSCTC Indoor Champions |
| 2016 |
| Matt Battaglia, jr. 800-meter run |
| Luis Rivera, sr. 35-pound weight throw |
|
| 2015 |
| Khiary Gayle, jr. triple jump |
| Nick LaBarbera, fr. 500-meter dash; Rookie of the Meet |
|
| 2013 |
| Jake Lafaver, jr. 800-meter run |
|
| 2010 |
| Roby Castor, gr. 800-meter run |
|
| 2008 |
| Brandon Wheeler, jr. 400-meter dash |
|
| 2007 |
| Nick Stenuf, jr. 800-meter run |
|
| 2006 |
| Nick Stenuf, soph. 800-meter run |
|
|
| Empire 8 Conference Indoor All-Stars |
| 2025 |
| Will D'Agata, fr. pole vault (third team) |
| David Dobrowolski, soph. (Sportsman of the Year) |
| Cade Eells, sr. mile (third team) |
| Graeden Heichberger, fr. shot put (third team) |
| Jack Pomykaj, jr. heptathlon (third team) |
|
| 2024 |
| Jason Bletsko, soph. pole vault (third team) |
| Nathan Bowers, gr. mile run (third team) |
| Nathan Bowers, gr. 3,000-meter run (third team) |
| Cade Eells, jr. 800-meter run (second team) |
| Cade Eells, jr. mile run (first team) |
| Cade Eells, jr. 3,000-meter run (second team) |
| Aaron Lund, soph. (Sportsman of the Year) |
| Aaron Lund, soph. 60-meter hurdles (third team) |
| Aaron Lund, soph. heptathlon (third team) |
| Kaleb Luton, gr. (Track Athlete of the Year) |
| Kaleb Luton, gr. 60-meter dash (first team) |
| Kaleb Luton, gr. 60-meter hurdles (first team) |
| Kaleb Luton, gr. triple jump (second team) |
| Connor McCauslin, gr. 60-meter hurdles (second team) |
| Jack Pomykaj, soph. pole vault (second team) |
| Jack Pomykaj, soph. heptathlon (first team) |
| Michael Puglisi, soph. 200-meter dash (third team) |
| Michael Puglisi, soph. 400-meter dash (first team) |
| Gabe Wilson, soph. long jump (third team) |
| Gabe Wilson soph. triple jump (third team) |
| 1,600-meter relay (Ben Lewis, Mike Welch, Jack Healy, Gavin McAllister) second team |
| Distance medley relay (Brennan Farr, Cole Hastings,Gavin McAllister, Ethan Kenyon) second team |
| James Goss, Coach of the Year |
|
| 2023 |
| Jason Bletsko, fr. pole vault (first team) |
| Nathan Bowers, sr. mile run (second team) |
| Nathan Bowers, sr. 3,000-meter run (first team) |
| Nathan Bowers, sr. 5,000-meter run (third team) |
| Cade Eells, soph. (Track Athlete of the Year) |
| Cade Eells, soph. 800-meter run (second team) |
| Cade Eells, soph. mile run (first team) |
| Cade Eells, soph. 3,000-meter run (second team) |
| Patrick Healy, gr. (Sportsman of the Year) |
| Ben Lewis, soph. 400-meter dash (first team) |
| Aaron Lund, fr. 60-meter hurdles (third team) |
| Aaron Lund, fr. heptathlon (third team) |
| Kaleb Luton, sr. 60-meter hurdles (first team) |
| Kaleb Luton, sr. triple jump (second team) |
| Gavin McAllister, fr. 800-meter run (third team) |
| Jack Pomykaj, fr. pole vault (second team) |
| Michael Puglisi, fr. (Rookie of the Year) |
| Michael Puglisi, fr. 200-meter dash (second team) |
| Michael Puglisi, fr. 400-meter dash (third team) |
| Mike Welch, sr. 400-meter dash (second team) |
| 1,600-meter relay (Mike Welch, Michael Puglisi, Gavin McAllister, Ben Lewis) first team |
| Distance medley relay (Kenny Williams, Joey Nettles, Lucas Sharron, Ethan Glashauser) first team |
| James Goss, Coach of the Year |
|
| 2022 |
| Nathan Bowers, jr. mile (second team) |
| Nathan Bowers, jr. 3,000-meter run (second team) |
| Nathan Bowers, jr. 5,000-meter run (second team) |
| Patrick Healy, sr. 800-meter run (third team) |
| Matt Johnson, sr. 400-meter dash (first team, Sportsman of the Year) |
| Matt Johnson, sr. triple jump (third team) |
| Ben Lewis, fr. 400-meter dash (second team) |
| Kaleb Luton, jr. (Track Athlete of the Year) |
| Connor McCauslin, jr. 60-meter hurdles (first team) |
| Connor McCauslin, jr. 60-meter dash (third team) |
| Christopher Perez, sr. 35-pound weight throw (first team) |
| Josh Pomerleau, sr. pole vault (second team) |
| Matt Reimann, soph. Torchbearer Award |
| Josh Tomaka, sr. mile run (third team) |
| 1,600-meter relay (Mike Welch, Ben Lewis, Joey Nettles, Patrick Healy) third team |
| Distance medley relay (Ethan Kenyon, Joey Nettles, Patrick Healy, Lucas Sharron) first team |
|
| 2021 |
| Nathan Bowers, soph. 5,000-meter run (first team) |
| Kaleb Luton, soph. triple jump (second team) |
| Connor McCauslin, soph. 60-meter dash (first team) |
| Connor McCauslin, soph. 60-meter hurdles (first team) |
| Josh Pomerleau, jr. pole vault (second team) |
| Jake Suddaby, jr. (Sportsman of the Year) |
| Josh Tomaka, jr. 3,000-meter run (second team) |
| 1,600-meter relay (Matt Johnson, Chris Celecki, Ahviere Reese, Mike Welch) second team |
| Distance medley relay (Chris Celecki, Ahviere Reese, Lucas Sharron, Jake Suddaby) first team |
|
| 2020 |
| Nathan Bowers, fr. 3,000-meter run (second team) |
| Josh Tomaka, soph. (Sportsman of the Year) |
| Distance medley relay (Josh Tomaka, Mike Welch, Christopher Celecki, Jason Hall) first team |
|
| 2019 |
| William Lewis, soph. (Sportsman of the Year) |
|
| 2018 |
| Nick LaBarbera, sr. 200-meter dash (second team) |
| Nick LaBarbera, sr. 400-meter dash (second team) |
|
| 2017 |
| Matt Battaglia, sr. 800-meter run (first team) |
|
| 2016 |
| Matt Battaglia, jr. 800-meter run (first team) |
| Nick LaBarbera, soph. 400 meter run (second team) |
| Luis Rivera, sr. 35-pound weight throw (first team) |
| Luis Rivera, sr. (Field Athlete of the Year) |
| Tom Sippie, sr. 400-meter dash (first team) |
| 1,600-meter relay (Nick LaBarbera, Matt Battaglia, Michael-Jordan Morris, Tom Sippie) first team |
|
| 2015 |
| Matt Battaglia, soph. 800-meter run (second team) |
| Khiary Gayle, jr. triple jump (first team) |
| Nick LaBarbera, fr. 400-meter dash (second team) |
| Luis Rivera, jr. 35-pound weight throw (first team) |
| Luis Rivera, jr. (co-Field Athelte of the Year) |
| Tom Sippie, jr. 400-meter dash (first team) |
| 1,600-meter relay (Nick LaBarbera, Matt Battaglia, Jacob Murray, Tom Sippie) second team |
|
| 2014 |
| Jake Lafaver, sr. 800-meter run (first team) |
| Jake Lafaver, sr. (Track Athlete of the Year) |
| Luis Rivera, soph. 35-pound weight throw (first team) |
|
| 2013 |
| Kiary Gayle, fr. triple jump (first team) |
| Jake Lafaver, jr. 400-meter dash (first team) |
| Jake Lafaver, jr. (Track Athlete of the Year) |
|
| 2012 |
| Ira Griffin, fr. (Track Athlete of the Meet) |
| Ira Griffin, fr. (Co-Rookie of the Year) |
| Ira Griffin, fr. 60-meter dash (first team) |
| 1,600-meter relay (Jake Lafaver, Philip Schierer, Dan Polino, Ira Griffin) first team |
|
| 2010 |
| Robby Castor, gr. mile run (first team) |
|
| 2009 |
| Matt Case, jr. 400-meter dash (first team) |
|
| 2008 |
| Matt Case, soph. 400-meter dash (second team) |
| Robby Castor, 1-mile run (second team) |
| Brendan Epstein, sr. 5,000-meter run (second team) |
| Nick Stenuf, sr. (Track Athlete of the Meet) |
| Nick Stenuf, sr. 1-mile run (first team) |
| Nick Stenuf, sr. 800-meter run (first team) |
| Brandon Wheeler, jr. 200-meter dash (second team) |
| Brandon Wheeler, jr. 400-meter dash (first team) |
| Brandon Wheeler, jr. high jump (first team) |
| 1,600-meter relay (Brandon Wheeler, Robby Castor, Matt Case, Nick Stenuf), first team |
| Distance Medley Relay (Aaron Sirtoli, Matt Morales, Paul Wheeler, Brendan Epstein) first team |
|
| 2007 |
| Matt Case, fr. 400-meter dash (second team) |
| Larry DiCesare, sr. (Sportsman of the Year) |
| Nick Stenuf, jr. 800-meter run (first team) |
| Brandon Wheeler, soph. 400-meter dash (first team) |
| Brandon Wheeler, soph. pentathlon (first team) |
| Brandon Wheeler, soph. (co-Field Athlete of the Year) |
| 800-meter relay (Brandon Wheeler, Matt Case, Justin Banks, Jon Qazi), second team |
| 1,600-meter relay (Brandon Wheeler, Craig Connelly, Matt Case, Nick Stenuf), first team |
|
| 2006 |
| Nick Stenuf, soph. (Athlete of the Meet) |
| Nick Stenuf, soph. 800-meter run (first team) |
| Brandon Wheeler, fr. high jump (second team) |
| 1,600-meter relay (Nick Amorese, Craig Connelly, Nick Stenuf, Brandon Wheeler), second team |
|
| 2005 |
| Craig Connelly, soph. pentathlon (second team) |
| Nick Stenuf, fr. 800-meter run (first team) |
