| NFCA All-Americans |
| 2025 |
| Kaijah Alexander, fr. 3B (third team) |
|
| NFCA Northeast Region/Region III All-Stars |
| 2026 |
| Ashley Bell, sr. 2B (first team) |
| Alexis Brown, fr. OF (first team) |
| Madison Hicks, soph. UT/P (second team) |
| Bryanna Moroughan, fr. SS (third team) |
|
| 2025 |
| Kaijah Alexander, fr. 3B (first team) |
| Morgan Russo, soph. 1B (first team) |
| Haleigh Suitor, soph. OH (third team) |
|
| 2019 |
| Sarah Simmons, fr. OF (third team) |
| Marissa Tortora, sr. 2B (second team) |
|
| 2010 |
| Kelly Kocher, so. P (first team) |
|
| 2009 |
| Lizzie Barlow, sr. 1B (third team) |
| Lisa Nazarenko, jr. P (third team) |
|
| Empire 8 Conference All-Stars |
| 2026 |
| Kaijah Alexander, soph. 3B (third team) |
| Ashley Bell, sr. 2B/At-Large (first team) |
| Alexis Brown, fr. OF (first team) |
| Madison Hicks, soph. DP (second team) |
| Bryanna Moroughan, fr. SS (third team) |
| Morgan Russo, jr. 1B (third team) |
| Maddy Spakoski, sr. OF (Tomorrow's Leader Award) |
| Haleigh Suitor, jr. OF (second team) |
|
| 2025 |
| Kaijah Alexander, fr. 3B (first team, Rookie of the Year) |
| Ashley Bell, jr. P/INF (Sportswoman of the Year) |
| Sarah Ferruzza, fr. OF (third team) |
| Madison Hicks, fr. DP (third team) |
| Morgan Russo, soph. 1B (first team) |
| Haleigh Suitor, soph. OH (first team) |
|
| 2024 |
| Morgan Russo, fr. C (third team, Sportswoman of the Year) |
| Maddy Spakoski, soph. OF (second team) |
|
| 2023 |
| Justine Brooks, gr. 1B (third team) |
| Emily Daciw, sr. P (second team) |
| Megan Pum, jr. 2B (Sportswoman of the Year) |
| Sarah Simmons, gr. OF (second team) |
|
| 2022 |
| Marissa Berghorn, soph. C (second team) |
| Justine Brooks, sr. 1B (third team) |
| Emily Daciw, jr. P (first team, Pitcher of the Year, Sportswoman of the Year) |
| Sarah Simmons, sr. OF (first team) |
|
| 2021 |
| Jessica Klem, jr. INF (Sportswoman of the Year) |
| Sarah Simmons, jr. OF (first team) |
| Janelle Walters, sr. OF (third team) |
|
| 2019 |
| Delaney St. George, sr. OF (Sportswoman of the Year) |
| Sarah Simmons, fr. OF (first team) |
| Marissa Tortora, sr. 2B (first team) |
|
| 2018 |
| Stephanie Mongelli, sr. 1B (second team, Sportswoman of the Year) |
| Marissa Tortora, jr. 2B (second team) |
| Janelle Walters, fr. OF (second team) |
|
| 2017 |
| Meghan Barry, sr. OF (honorable mention) |
| Rachel Mertens, sr. P (first team) |
| Marissa Tortora, soph. SS (honorable mention) |
| Nicole White, sr. UTIL (first team, Sportswoman of the Year) |
| Jack Carpenter (Coach of the Year) |
|
| 2016 |
| Maureen Rogers, sr. 1B (first team) |
| Carly Pike, sr. 3B (Sportswoman of the Year) |
|
| 2015 |
| Stephanie Mongelli, fr. UTIL (Sportswoman of the Year) |
|
| 2014 |
| Carly Pike, so. 3B (honorable mention) |
| Kailey Ritch, sr. 2B (Sportswoman of the Year) |
|
| 2013 |
| Sarah Cipperly, jr. SS (honorable mention) |
| Meg DeMario, jr. OF (Sportswoman of the Year) |
| Carly Pike, fr. UTIL (first team) |
|
| 2012 |
| Kailey Ritch, so. 2B (Sportswoman of the Year) |
|
| 2011 |
| Jessica Mangicaro, sr. OF (Sportswoman of the Year) |
|
| 2010 |
| Kelley Horbal, sr. OF (Sportswoman of the Year) |
| Kelly Kocher, so. P (first team, Pitcher of the Year) |
| Ann Schoff, sr. 1B (second team) |
|
| 2009 |
| Lizzie Barlow, sr. 1B (second team) |
| Polly Muehlenkamp, jr. (Sportswoman of the Year) |
| Lisa Nazarenko, jr. UTIL (honorable mention) |
| Laura Persico, sr. OF (second team) |
|
| 2008 |
| Laura Finan, so. (Sportswoman of the Year) |
| Christa Harris, jr. 3B (honorable mention) |
| Lisa Nazarenko, so. P (first team) |
| Laura Persico, jr. UTIL (first team) |
|
| 2007 |
| Lizzie Barlow, so. first base (second team) |
| Christa Harris, so. (Sportswoman of the Year) |
