| 1986 (Scott Nelson, 8-3) | Roster |
| 3/22 |
Potsdam 13, Nazareth 8 (at Coyne Field, Syracuse, N.Y.) |
| 3/28 |
Nazareth 24, Syracuse Club 7 (A) |
| 4/2 |
Nazareth 20, Pace 5 (A) |
| 4/3 |
Nazareth 21, Kean, N.J. 6 (A) |
| 4/5 |
Nazareth 12, Hartwick 10 (A) |
| 4/9 |
Nazareth 13, Hobart 'B' 12, ot (H) |
| 4/12 |
LeMoyne 13, Nazareth 9 (H) |
| 4/15 |
Nazareth 15, Morrisville Tech 7 (H) |
| 4/19 |
Nazareth 14, Rochester 10 (A) |
| 4/22 |
Buffalo State 18, Nazareth 7 (A) |
| 4/25 |
Nazareth 23, Elmira 3 (H) |
|
|
| 1987 (Scott Nelson, 8-5) | Roster |
| 3/18 |
Hampden-Sydney, Va. 16, Nazareth 9 (A) |
| 3/21 |
Nazareth 15, Wooster, Ohio 6 (at Mt. Washington Lacrosse Club, Baltimore, Md.) |
| 3/25 |
Nazareth 17, Morrisville Tech 6 (A) |
| 3/29 |
Washington, Md. 15, Nazareth 7 (H) |
| 4/1 |
Geneseo 10, Nazareth 7 (A) |
| 4/11 |
Nazareth 12, Oswego 4 (H) |
| 4/12 |
Nazareth 11, LeMoyne 10 (A) |
| 4/15 |
Alfred 9, Nazareth 8 (A) |
| 4/18 |
Nazareth 10, Stony Brook 8 (A) |
| 4/21 |
Nazareth 24, Buffalo State 8 (H) |
| 4/24 |
Potsdam 12, Nazareth 5 (at Coyne Field, Syracuse, N.Y.) |
| 4/26 |
Nazareth 16, Hartwick 5 (H) |
| 4/28 |
Nazareth 10, Rochester 5 (H) |
|
|
| 1988 (Scott Nelson, 11-3) | Roster |
| Captains: Dave Basile, Tom Coons, Rocky Garofalo, Gerry Gutchess |
| 3/12 |
Nazareth 30, Southampton 1 (at Rutgers University, Piscataway, N.J.) |
| 3/16 |
Nazareth 12, Salisbury State 7 (A) |
| 3/18 |
Nazareth 27, New York Maritime 3 (A) |
| 3/26 |
Nazareth 11, LeMoyne 2 (H) |
| 3/28 |
Nazareth 19, Rochester 4 (A) |
| 4/2 |
Nazareth 16, Hartwick 10 (A) |
| 4/9 |
Nazareth 11, Oswego 6 (A) |
| 4/13 |
Nazareth 16, Alfred 4 (H) |
| 4/16 |
Nazareth 18, Stony Brook 6 (H) |
| 4/19 |
Hobart 15, Nazareth 9 (A) |
| 4/23 |
Nazareth 16, Potsdam 7 (H) |
| 4/30 |
Washington, Md. 16, Nazareth 6 (A) |
| 5/3 |
Nazareth 25, Geneseo 5 (H) |
| 5/11 |
Hobart 17, Nazareth 12 (A) NCAA Tournament |
|
|
| 1989 (Scott Nelson, 11-5) | Roster |
| Captains: Dave Basile, Bill Coons, Tom Coons, Gerry Gutchess |
| 3/18 |
Nazareth 10, Lehigh 7 (at Penn State Tournament, State College, Pa.) |
| 3/19 |
Penn State 12, Nazareth 10 (A) at Penn State Tournament, State College, Pa. |
| 3/25 |
Nazareth 19, Pfeiffer 2 (at Loyola College, Baltimore, Md.) |
| 3/28 |
Nazareth 17, Salisbury State 11 (A) |
| 4/1 |
Ohio Wesleyan 12, Nazareth 7 (at Hofstra University, Hempstead, N.Y.) |
| 4/4 |
Nazareth 15, Geneseo 9 (A) |
| 4/12 |
Alfred 11, Nazareth 7 (A) |
| 4/15 |
Nazareth 29, LeMoyne 6 (A) |
| 4/19 |
Hobart 9, Nazareth 5 (H) |
| 4/22 |
Nazareth 16, Potsdam 8 (A) |
| 4/26 |
Nazareth 14, Cortland 3 (H) |
| 4/28 |
Nazareth 20, Hartwick 10 (at East Rochester H.S.) |
| 5/1 |
Nazareth 21, Oswego 6 (H) |
| 5/2 |
Nazareth 17, Rochester 4 (H) |
| 5/10 |
Nazareth 25, Salisbury State 10 (H) NCAA Tournament |
| 5/14 |
Hobart 14, Nazareth 10 (A) NCAA Tournament |
|
|
| 1990 (Scott Nelson, 11-5) | Roster | Team Pic |
| Captains: John McAuliffe, Bill Meagher, Dana Ryan |
| 3/17 |
Nazareth 10, Ohio Wesleyan 5 (at Washington College Tournament, Chestertown, Md.) |
| 3/18 |
Washington, Md. 12, Nazareth 8 (at Washington College Tournament, Chestertown, Md.) |
| 3/24 |
Nazareth 14, Ithaca 7 (H) |
| 3/31 |
RIT 12, Nazareth 10 (H) |
| 4/3 |
Nazareth 11, Geneseo 6 (H) |
| 4/7 |
Hartwick 12, Nazareth 11 (A) |
| 4/11 |
Alfred 6, Nazareth 5 (H) |
| 4/14 |
Nazareth 9, Oswego 3 (A) |
| 4/18 |
Hobart 18, Nazareth 11 (A) |
| 4/21 |
Nazareth 13, Potsdam 10 (H) |
| 4/25 |
Nazareth 13, Cortland 12, ot (A) |
| 4/28 |
Nazareth 22, St. Lawrence 8 (A) |
| 4/30 |
Nazareth 20, Rochester 8 (A) |
| 5/1 |
Nazareth 30, Canisius 9 (H) |
| 5/4 |
Nazareth 19, Union 10 (H) ECAC Upstate Tournament |
| 5/6 |
Nazareth 25, Potsdam 14 (H) ECAC Upstate Tournament |
|
|
| 1991 (Scott Nelson, 12-2) | Roster | Team Pic |
| Captains: Greg Gebhardt, Carl Jutzin, Marty Kelly, Rich Pierpont |
| 3/19 |
Nazareth 29, Canisius 5 (A) |
| 3/23 |
Nazareth 9, Ithaca 7 (A) |
| 3/30 |
Nazareth 18, RIT 5 (A) |
| 4/2 |
Nazareth 18, Geneseo 10 (A) |
| 4/6 |
Nazareth 13, Hartwick 9 (H) |
| 4/10 |
Nazareth 18, Alfred 10 (A) |
| 4/13 |
Nazareth 22, Oswego 7 (H) |
| 4/17 |
Hobart 19, Nazareth 12 (H) |
| 4/20 |
Nazareth 21, Potsdam 4 (A) |
| 4/24 |
Nazareth 17, Cortland 4 (H) |
| 4/27 |
Nazareth 16, St. Lawrence 12 (H) |
| 4/30 |
Nazareth 22, Rochester 3 (H) |
| 5/8 |
Nazareth 17, Gettysburg 10 (A) NCAA Tournament |
| 5/13 |
Hobart 19, Nazareth 17 (A) NCAA Tournament |
|
|
| 1992 (Scott Nelson, 14-1, NCAA Division III champions) | Roster | Team Pic |
| Captains: Greg Gebhardt, Carl Jutzin, Marty Kelly, Pete Riley, Brian Silcott |
| 3/18 |
Nazareth 17, Connecticut College 4 (at Roanoke College, Salem, Va.) |
| 3/21 |
Nazareth 13, Roanoke 12 (A) |
| 3/28 |
Nazareth 12, RIT 7 (at Fauver Stadium, Rochester, N.Y.) |
| 3/31 |
Nazareth 15, Geneseo 4 (H) |
| 4/5 |
Nazareth 22, Bentley 4 (H) |
| 4/11 |
Nazareth 14, St. Lawrence 8 (at Hamilton College, Clinton, N.Y.) |
| 4/15 |
Hobart 13, Nazareth 12 (A) |
| 4/18 |
Nazareth 19, Potsdam 3 (H) |
| 4/22 |
Nazareth 15, Cortland 14, ot (A) |
| 4/25 |
Nazareth 16, Clarkson 5 (at SUNY Cortland, Cortland, N.Y.) |
| 4/27 |
Nazareth 17, Oswego 10 (A) |
| 4/28 |
Nazareth 20, Rochester 4 (A) |
| 5/10 |
Nazareth 22, Clarkson 11 (H) NCAA Tournament |
| 5/17 |
Nazareth 13, Hobart 12, ot (A) NCAA Tournament |
| 5/24 |
Nazareth 22, Roanoke 11 (NCAA Championship game at Franklin Field, Philadelphia, Pa.) |
|
|
| 1993 (Scott Nelson, 10-3) | Roster |
| Captains: Joe Alden, Cam Bomberry, Jim Cornicelli, Jeremy Hollenbeck, Brian Silcott |
| 3/17 |
Salisbury State 10, Nazareth 7 (A) |
| 3/21 |
C.W. Post 9, Nazareth 7 (at St. John's University, Queens, N.Y.) |
| 3/27 |
Nazareth 18, RIT 7 (at Canisius College, Buffalo, N.Y.) |
| 3/31 |
Nazareth 19, Geneseo 6 (H) |
| 4/5 |
Nazareth 14, Oswego 3 (H) |
| 4/6 |
Nazareth 17, LeMoyne 9 (at Carrier Dome, Syracuse, N.Y.) |
| 4/10 |
Nazareth 9, St. Lawrence 8 (H) |
| 4/17 |
Nazareth 17, Roanoke 13 (H) |
| 4/21 |
Nazareth 13, Cortland 6 (H) |
| 4/23 |
Nazareth 17, Canisius 3 (H) |
| 4/27 |
Nazareth 16, Ithaca 7 (H) |
| 5/16 |
Nazareth 15, Alfred 8 (H) NCAA Tournament |
| 5/23 |
Hobart 20, Nazareth 16 (A) NCAA Tournament |
|
|
| 1994 (Scott Nelson, 12-2) | Roster |
| Captains: Cam Bomberry, Kevin Cox, Jeremy Hollenbeck, Pat Metzler, Rich Petersen |
| 3/19 |
Nazareth 16, Roanoke 8 (A) |
| 3/26 |
Nazareth 16, RIT 7 (H) |
| 3/29 |
Nazareth 19, Geneseo 2 (H) |
| 4/2 |
Nazareth 23, LeMoyne 6 (H) |
| 4/6 |
Nazareth 19, Canisius 10 (A) |
| 4/9 |
Nazareth 12, St. Lawrence 9 (A) |
| 4/17 |
Salisbury State 21, Nazareth 2 (H) |
| 4/20 |
Nazareth 16, Cortland 7 (A) |
| 4/23 |
Nazareth 12, SC.W. Post 11 (H) |
| 4/27 |
Nazaereth 18, Ithaca 15 (A) |
| 5/4 |
Nazareth 14, Oswego 8 (A) |
| 5/7 |
Nazareth 16, Ohio Wesleyan 13 (A) |
| 5/15 |
Nazareth 14, RIT 13, ot (H) NCAA Tournament |
| 5/22 |
Hobart 18, Nazareth 14 (A) NCAA Tournament |
|
|
| 1995 (Scott Nelson, 14-1) | Roster |
| Captains: Ed Geary, Brian Majczak, Chuck Roberts |
| 3/18 |
Nazareth 18, Hampden-Sydney 12 (at Old Dominion University, Norfolk, Va.) |
| 3/25 |
Nazareth 13, RIT 7 (A) |
| 3/28 |
Nazareth 12, Geneseo 4 (A) |
| 4/1 |
Nazareth 17, LeMoyne 5 (A) |
| 4/8 |
Nazareth 16, St. Lawrence 8 (H) |
| 4/12 |
Nazareth 13, Cortland 7 (H) |
| 4/15 |
Nazareth 12, Bentley (A) |
| 4/19 |
Nazareth 18, Canisius 10 (H) |
| 4/22 |
Nazareth 15, C.W. Post 10 (A) |
| 4/26 |
Nazareth 13, Ithaca 9 (H) |
| 4/29 |
Nazareth 17, Ohio Wesleyan 14 (H) |
| 5/3 |
Nazareth 17, Oswego 6 (H) |
| 5/14 |
Nazareth 16, Hartwick 8 (H) NCAA Tournament |
| 5/21 |
Nazareth 14, Ohio Wesleyan 13 (H) NCAA Tournament |
| 5/28 |
Salisbury State 22, Nazareth 13 (NCAA Championship game at Byrd Stadium, College Park, Md.) |
